Today's Articles


Question:

A story of love, adoption and friendship spanning thousands of miles has been written as a lasting memento to two special little boys. We are the adoptive mothers of two beautiful South Korean toddlers. Our little treasures were born only eight days apart and were in the same nursery for the first six weeks of their lives before being sent to separate foster homes.  They were both put up for international adoption and as it turns out, they ended up half an hour away from each other and have since become good friends. We both felt that our son’s journey was special and worth sharing.  We have written their story in a children’s book on adoption and friendship titled "Friends for Life".  It’s a valuable tool to explain adoption not only to an adoptive child but to any child .  It’s a great story with a very happy ending! For more information, please visit our web site at http://www.editionstrian.com A timeless bedtime story that your child will want to hear over and over again! Nathalie and Marie-Josee

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -A story of love, adoption and friendship spanning thousands of miles has been written as a lasting memento to two special little boys. We are the adoptive mothers of two beautiful South Korean toddlers. Our little treasures were born only eight days apart and were in the same nursery for the first six weeks of their lives before being sent to separate foster homes.  They were both put up for international adoption and as it turns out, they ended up half an hour away from each other and have since become good friends. We both felt that our son’s journey was special and worth sharing.  We have written their story in a children’s book on adoption and friendship titled "Friends for Life".  It’s a valuable tool to explain adoption not only to an adoptive child but to any child .  It’s a great story with a very happy ending! For more information, please visit our web site at http://www.editionstrian.com A timeless bedtime story that your child will want to hear over and over again! Nathalie and Marie-Josee

Sorry…but BARF!! KL

Response:

Sorry…but BARF!! KL

Yeah, sorry, I’m sure it’s a sweet story, but, blargh!

Response:

Question:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Sorry, that’s a very bad example.  The woman’s boyfriend left her early on in her pregnancy–after she left her home and moved to NY.   Her pregnancy was not hidden.   She had ample time–months– to investigate her options. But she knew (thanks to baby dumps) that she did not have to.. She could have been referred into any numerous mother-child care plans, including adoption–that would have helped her make an ethical decision. Instead, she was irresponsible, and didn’t want to bother with all that complicated counseling and paper signing. And she makes one of the biggest decisions of her life by default.. Good responsible citizen building.. The abandonment was an abandonment of convenience–a drive-by dump. And the folks cheer and cheer again.. The good guys have won….. The baby is held by the fireman for a photo op… Another baby saved, from what we are not told. Ron Jackie

A mother with a hair weave from what I could tell from the shadows. Marley – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text –

Response:

snip Another baby saved, from what we are not told. A mother with a hair weave from what I could tell from the shadows.

  That’s one lucky baby!  He sure had a narrow escape! Ghoulagirl. "Damn, I’ll burn you into a BBQ chicken!"                                 – from "Actual English Subtitles Used In Japanese Films", found at n3t.net/humor/subtitles.html

Response:

I see nothing has changed in here.  Still the baby hating, adoptee hating nutcases you’ve always been.  UNBELIEVEABLE!!!  that you’d rather a baby dead than abandoned.  My advice— marley, ghoul and those who agree with them, get therapy.

Response:

<<I see nothing has changed in here.  Still the baby hating, adoptee hating nutcases you’ve always been.  UNBELIEVEABLE!!!  that you’d rather a baby dead than abandoned.  My advice— marley, ghoul and those who agree with them, get therapy. I wholeheartedly agree! Finally somebody that makes some sense around here. Jean "We aim above the mark to hit the mark." Ralph Waldo Emerson

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – <<I see nothing has changed in here.  Still the baby hating, adoptee hating nutcases you’ve always been.  UNBELIEVEABLE!!!  that you’d rather a baby dead than abandoned.  My advice— marley, ghoul and those who agree with them, get therapy. I wholeheartedly agree! Finally somebody that makes some sense around here. Jean "We aim above the mark to hit the mark." Ralph Waldo Emerson

FuckRoy is such an idiot, he almost makes YOU look sane.  Two of a kind… I’m so not surprised you’d agree with each other. Kathy, born Renee Karyn Racine Permanent good can never be the outcome of untruth and violence. –Mahatma Gandhi         Peace is not merely a distant goal that we seek, but a means by which we arrive at that goal. –Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.    

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Sorry, that’s a very bad example.  The woman’s boyfriend left her early on in her pregnancy–after she left her home and moved to NY.   Her pregnancy was not hidden.   She had ample time–months– to investigate her options. But she knew (thanks to baby dumps) that she did not have to.. She could have been referred into any numerous mother-child care plans, including adoption–that would have helped her make an ethical decision. Instead, she was irresponsible, and didn’t want to bother with all that complicated counseling and paper signing. And she makes one of the biggest decisions of her life by default.. Good responsible citizen building.. The abandonment was an abandonment of convenience–a drive-by dump. And the folks cheer and cheer again.. The good guys have won….. The baby is held by the fireman for a photo op…

Another baby saved, from what we are not told. Ron – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Jackie

Response:

Sorry, that’s a very bad example.  The woman’s boyfriend left her early on in her pregnancy–after she left her home and moved to NY.   Her pregnancy was not hidden.   She had ample time–months– to investigate her options.

But she knew (thanks to baby dumps) that she did not have to.. She could have been referred into any numerous mother-child care plans, including adoption–that would have helped her make an ethical decision. Instead, she was irresponsible, and didn’t want to bother with all that complicated counseling and paper signing.

And she makes one of the biggest decisions of her life by default.. Good responsible citizen building.. The abandonment was an abandonment of convenience–a drive-by dump.

And the folks cheer and cheer again.. The good guys have won….. The baby is held by the fireman for a photo op… Jackie

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – <<<Who’s ranting, Jean? Marley,  Question already answered, as I must say that was a good one. :-) <<<< I’m not the one with the fetish for dead babies. I only have a desire to have newborns stay alive. <<<  Do you channel Debi Faris? That depends on what channel my cordless phone is on, as I’ve spoken to her on it, and she is a wonderful person who is dedicated to helping save the lives of newborns. And she cries on cue, too–for camera and politicians.  Ever ask her about her problems with the State of California?

Debi’s a piece of work. Jean and Debi must have a lot to chat about, both have hubbies who are "old newspapermen", they’re both tragedy pimps, anyone who disagrees with them, even if they’ve actually worked with and counseled desparate women through abandonment (which neither of them have, incidently), are the "enemy". We also have support from a former political official who is an adoptee. We’ll let him speak for himself when the time is appropriate.

Gerald Ford unplugged? Ron – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Jean Well, good for you. And I spent the afternoon with a woman who was abandoned in a church and ya know what–she detests  these laws.   It’s what we call diversity. Marley Baby Bumble <<<Marley Baby Bumble

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Albeit an angry, frustrated, and often lonely one. And your solution is that death is better then what you allege is a lonely, frustrated life. Jean <<By what right do you dare to speak for those who have been abandoned without <<an identity? <<By what right do you dare to speak for adopted people?  By what right too <<you purse you agenda of creating anonymous people? <<Marley Dear Marley, I have never claimed to speak for a single adopted person. And not for a person who was abandoned.  I only speak in favor of Baby Safe Haven laws that have saved the lives of many newborns, and will hopefully save the lives of many more.

Jean, you cannot say with any degree of certaintly that Safe Haven laws have saved one baby, let alone many babies, for the simple and irrefutable reason that the laws are designed to obscure who abandons. I do not want to see another tragedy, such as the baby I buried. Marley, have you ever looked at the face of a newborn who was left out in the elements for a couple of days?  I can tell you that it’s a picture in your memory that you will never forget.

I’m certain that it’s horrible. And, indeed, I know of no one on either side of the debate over the efficacy and ethics of safe Havens that does not think and feel that infant abandonment is a tragedy. If Baby Safe Haven laws can prevent another tragedy like that, I’ll continue to advocate for their positive outcome.

Well, then why don’t you work with us on a solution? Don’t forget that babies brought to a safe havens can be reunited with their birth mothers and fathers, and a percentage are reunited with their birth families, not always adopted.  They are also alive, tell me how that is a bad outcome? Don’t forget that if you are alive, you can find your identity, or your birth mother can come forward with it at any time.

The argument isn’t over dead babies and identity: the argument is over the inherent contradictions that will, I feel, eventually sink Safe Haven programs, because they aren’t really designed very well. Let’s not forget there are many adoptees who favor Baby Safe Haven laws. A few very prominent ones are working with us here in MA.

That’s as may be. There are adoptees who are pro and anti abortion – we are not a monolithic group. ants, as I know you will.  :-) Jean

As most of your discourse is laced with dead babies. Ron

Response:

<<<Who’s ranting, Jean? Marley,  Question already answered, as I must say that was a good one. :-) <<<< I’m not the one with the fetish for dead babies. I only have a desire to have newborns stay alive. <<<  Do you channel Debi Faris? That depends on what channel my cordless phone is on, as I’ve spoken to her on it, and she is a wonderful person who is dedicated to helping save the lives of newborns.

And she cries on cue, too–for camera and politicians.  Ever ask her about her problems with the State of California? – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – <<<  I still can’t quite grasp why you believe that a woman who would kill her newborn is going to hook up with a hospital, cop, social worker–or any "responsible person."  For the uninitiated, in some states, a newborn may be left with any "responsible person."  As an old friend of mine, a Lt.,  EMS and First Responder at a fire department south of here who detests SH laws (as does the fire chief and captain), "John Wayne Gacey was once considered a "responsible person."  Then there was that rather disturbed woman in Detroit a couple years ago who left her baby with a "responsible person" at a bus stop who killed the baby. I guess that this means that you would be considered a responsible person too, as I’m sure you would call 911 to have the baby taken to the nearest

hospital. That’s not the point, though.  Since when it is considered good social policy to turn babies over to perfect strangers?  BTW, I don’t do babies.  I wouldn’t know what to do with one. <<<<Please give us some verifiable, documented case histories of Baby Moses drop-offs, including interviews with anon. women who were on the verge of tossing their babies in dumpsters when a light bulb went off over their heads. Oh, no, I’ll just turn it over to that nice hospital. The one that brought the baby to the Baystate medical center in Springfield last Feb.

Was there an interview?   Is it documented?  Does the public have access to the evidence?  And I recall a woman who was interviewed, and a tape aired on the John Walsh Show you were on that said just what you asked for.  Safe Haven laws are a life saver, I believe her quote was, but I’ll go back and check the

tape. Sorry, that’s a very bad example.  The woman’s boyfriend left her early on in her pregnancy–after she left her home and moved to NY.   Her pregnancy was not hidden.   She had ample time–months– to investigate her options. She could have been referred into any numerous mother-child care plans, including adoption–that would have helped her make an ethical decision. Instead, she was irresponsible, and didn’t want to bother with all that complicated counseling and paper signing.  The abandonment was an abandonment of convenience–a drive-by dump.   I’ve got a great deal of respect for Tim, but he blew this one. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – <<<<Finally, I’d still like to know what a "prominent adoptee" is? There’s a Prominent Adoptees Club in Boston?  Debbie Harry?  Ray Liotta?  Mary Gauthier? Craig Lucas?  Edward Albee? (Oh, I can just imagine what Edward would say about this.)  And why isn’t Tobin speaking publicly?  Why is his brother speaking for him?  Not that I particularly disbelieve you, but I’ve never heard anything about him speaking on his own. It’s always through his brother.  Of course, adopted persons are used to everybody else speaking for us. Councillor Tobin would only speak with the full support of his brother, and his close knit family.  Their decision is likely based on Councillor Tobin’s prominent public position to be the spokesperson for them.  Their public and/or private positions and spokesperson is their decision alone.

Well, wouldn’t you be suspicious if I were running around claiming  that MY brother –or anybody for that matter–was opposed to baby dumps, while that person remained silent.  Unless you put your mouth where your money is, it’s hinkey.  But then we are talking about anonymity, aren’t we?   Should it surprise us that anonymous people support anonymous-making laws? We also have support from a former political official who is an adoptee. We’ll let him speak for himself when the time is appropriate. Jean

Well, good for you. And I spent the afternoon with a woman who was abandoned in a church and ya know what–she detests  these laws.   It’s what we call diversity. Marley Baby Bumble – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – <<<Marley Baby Bumble

Response:

ChewToy: <<I see nothing has changed in here.  Still the baby hating, adoptee hating nutcases you’ve always been.  UNBELIEVEABLE!!!  that you’d rather a baby dead than abandoned.  My advice— marley, ghoul and those who agree with them, get therapy. I wholeheartedly agree! Finally somebody that makes some sense around here.

  ROROR!! Ghoulagirl. "Damn, I’ll burn you into a BBQ chicken!"                                 – from "Actual English Subtitles Used In Japanese Films", found at n3t.net/humor/subtitles.html

Response:

(DSAngelMom) writes:

FuckRoy: <<I see nothing has changed in here.  Still the baby hating, adoptee hating nutcases you’ve always been.  UNBELIEVEABLE!!!  that you’d rather a baby dead than abandoned.  My advice— marley, ghoul and those who agree with them, get therapy. I wholeheartedly agree! Finally somebody that makes some sense around here. This made my day. ;-}

  No kidding.  It brought a smile to my face for sure! Ghoulagirl. "Damn, I’ll burn you into a BBQ chicken!"                                 – from "Actual English Subtitles Used In Japanese Films", found at n3t.net/humor/subtitles.html

Response:

I see nothing has changed in here.  Still the baby hating, adoptee hating nutcases you’ve always been.  UNBELIEVEABLE!!!  that you’d rather a baby dead than abandoned.  My advice— marley, ghoul and those who agree with them, get therapy.

  Oh fuck off, Roy. Ghoulagirl. "Damn, I’ll burn you into a BBQ chicken!"                                 – from "Actual English Subtitles Used In Japanese Films", found at n3t.net/humor/subtitles.html

Response:

<<I see nothing has changed in here.  Still the baby hating, adoptee hating nutcases you’ve always been.  UNBELIEVEABLE!!!  that you’d rather a baby dead than abandoned.  My advice— marley, ghoul and those who agree with them, get therapy. I wholeheartedly agree! Finally somebody that makes some sense around here. Jean

Now THAT is funny.  Thanks for the yucks, Jean. Jack

Response:

I see nothing has changed in here.  Still the baby hating, adoptee hating nutcases you’ve always been.  UNBELIEVEABLE!!!  that you’d rather a baby dead than abandoned.  My advice— marley, ghoul and those who agree with them, get therapy.

And you’re still a stupid lying asshole – who cares? Robyn Resident Witchypoo & EAC Spellcaster #1557

Response:

(DSAngelMom) writes: <<I see nothing has changed in here.  Still the baby hating, adoptee hating nutcases you’ve always been.  UNBELIEVEABLE!!!  that you’d rather a baby dead than abandoned.  My advice— marley, ghoul and those who agree with them, get therapy. I wholeheartedly agree! Finally somebody that makes some sense around here.

This made my day. ;-} Jean "We aim above the mark to hit the mark." Ralph Waldo Emerson

J. Reply to jmhjmdATaolDOTcom

Response:

<<I see nothing has changed in here.  Still the baby hating, adoptee hating nutcases you’ve always been.  UNBELIEVEABLE!!!  that you’d rather a baby dead than abandoned.  My advice— marley, ghoul and those who agree with them, get therapy. I wholeheartedly agree! Finally somebody that makes some sense around here. Jean

Truly hilarious. Well, they do say as it takes one to know one. Rh. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – "We aim above the mark to hit the mark." Ralph Waldo Emerson

Response:

<<I see nothing has changed in here.  Still the baby hating, adoptee hating nutcases you’ve always been.  UNBELIEVEABLE!!!  that you’d rather a baby dead than abandoned.  My advice— marley, ghoul and those who agree with them, get therapy. I wholeheartedly agree! Finally somebody that makes some sense around here. Jean

It figures. One advocates for lowered standards in international adoption from corruption plagued baby selling havens like Romania and works for a disreputable unlicensed facilitator, the other pimps dead babies for political gain at the expense of women in crisis and their babies. You make a grand partnership. Ron – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – "We aim above the mark to hit the mark." Ralph Waldo Emerson

Response:

I see nothing has changed in here.  Still the baby hating, adoptee hating nutcases you’ve always been.  UNBELIEVEABLE!!!  that you’d rather a baby dead than abandoned.

You’re a liar and an oaf, still. Ron My advice— marley, ghoul and those who agree with them, get – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – therapy.

Response:

<<<Who’s ranting, Jean? Marley,  Question already answered, as I must say that was a good one.  :-) <<<< I’m not the one with the fetish for dead babies. I only have a desire to have newborns stay alive. <<<  Do you channel Debi Faris? That depends on what channel my cordless phone is on, as I’ve spoken to her on it, and she is a wonderful person who is dedicated to helping save the lives of newborns. <<<  I still can’t quite grasp why you believe that a woman who would kill her newborn is going to hook up with a hospital, cop, social worker–or any "responsible person."  For the uninitiated, in some states, a newborn may be left with any "responsible person."  As an old friend of mine, a Lt.,  EMS and First Responder at a fire department south of here who detests SH laws (as does the fire chief and captain), "John Wayne Gacey was once considered a "responsible person."  Then there was that rather disturbed woman in Detroit a couple years ago who left her baby with a "responsible person" at a bus stop who killed the baby. I guess that this means that you would be considered a responsible person too, as I’m sure you would call 911 to have the baby taken to the nearest hospital. <<<<Please give us some verifiable, documented case histories of Baby Moses drop-offs, including interviews with anon. women who were on the verge of tossing their babies in dumpsters when a light bulb went off over their heads. Oh, no, I’ll just turn it over to that nice hospital. The one that brought the baby to the Baystate medical center in Springfield last Feb.   And I recall a woman who was interviewed, and a tape aired on the John Walsh Show you were on that said just what you asked for.  Safe Haven laws are a life saver, I believe her quote was, but I’ll go back and check the tape. <<<<Finally, I’d still like to know what a "prominent adoptee" is?  There’s a Prominent Adoptees Club in Boston?  Debbie Harry?  Ray Liotta?  Mary Gauthier? Craig Lucas?  Edward Albee? (Oh, I can just imagine what Edward would say about this.)  And why isn’t Tobin speaking publicly?  Why is his brother speaking for him?  Not that I particularly disbelieve you, but I’ve never heard anything about him speaking on his own. It’s always through his brother.  Of course, adopted persons are used to everybody else speaking for us. Councillor Tobin would only speak with the full support of his brother, and his close knit family.  Their decision is likely based on Councillor Tobin’s prominent public position to be the spokesperson for them.  Their public and/or private positions and spokesperson is their decision alone. We also have support from a former political official who is an adoptee. We’ll let him speak for himself when the time is appropriate. Jean <<<Marley Baby Bumble

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Albeit an angry, frustrated, and often lonely one. And your solution is that death is better then what you allege is a lonely, frustrated life. Jean <<By what right do you dare to speak for those who have been abandoned without <<an identity? <<By what right do you dare to speak for adopted people?  By what right too <<you purse you agenda of creating anonymous people? <<Marley Dear Marley, I have never claimed to speak for a single adopted person. And not for a person who was abandoned.  I only speak in favor of Baby Safe Haven laws that have saved the lives of many newborns, and will hopefully save the lives of many more.  I do not want to see another tragedy, such as the baby I buried. Marley, have you ever looked at the face of a newborn who was left out in the elements for a couple of days?  I can tell you that it’s a picture in your memory that you will never forget. If Baby Safe Haven laws can prevent another tragedy like that, I’ll continue to advocate for their positive outcome. Don’t forget that babies brought to a safe havens can be reunited with their birth mothers and fathers, and a percentage are reunited with their birth families, not always adopted.  They are also alive, tell me how that is a bad outcome? Don’t forget that if you are alive, you can find your identity, or your birth mother can come forward with it at any time. Let’s not forget there are many adoptees who favor Baby Safe Haven laws. A few very prominent ones are working with us here in MA. Now go ahead and go off on one of your rants, as I know you will.  :-) Jean

Who’s ranting, Jean?  I’m not the one with the fetish for dead babies.  Do you channel Debi Faris?  I still can’t quite grasp why you believe that a woman who would kill her newborn is going to hook up with a hospital, cop, social worker–or any "responsible person."  For the uninitiated, in some states, a newborn may be left with any "responsible person."  As an old friend of mine, a Lt.,  EMS and First Responder at a fire department south of here who detests SH laws (as does the fire chief and captain), "John Wayne Gacey was once considered a "responsible person."  Then there was that rather disturbed woman in Detroit a couple years ago who left her baby with a "responsible person" at a bus stop who killed the baby. Please give us some verifiable, documented case histories of Baby Moses drop-offs, including interviews with anon. women who were on the verge of tossing their babies in dumpsters when a light bulb went off over their heads.  Oh, no, I’ll just turn it over to that nice hospital. Finally, I’d still like to know what a "prominent adoptee" is?  There’s a Prominent Adoptees Club in Boston?  Debbie Harry?  Ray Liotta?  Mary Gauthier?  Craig Lucas?  Edward Albee? (Oh, I can just imagine what Edward would say about this.)  And why isn’t Tobin speaking publicly?  Why is his brother speaking for him?  Not that I particularly disbelieve you, but I’ve never heard anything about him speaking on his own. It’s always through his brother.  Of course, adopted persons are used to everybody else speaking for us. Marley Baby Bumble – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text –

Response:

snip I only speak in favor of Baby Safe Haven laws that have saved the lives of many newborns, and will hopefully save the lives of many more.  I do not want to see another tragedy, such as the baby I buried.

  Oh, did you dump a baby somewhere unsafe?  How irresponsible! Ghoulagirl. "Damn, I’ll burn you into a BBQ chicken!"                                 – from "Actual English Subtitles Used In Japanese Films", found at n3t.net/humor/subtitles.html

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Albeit an angry, frustrated, and often lonely one. And your solution is that death is better then what you allege is a lonely, frustrated life. Jean <<By what right do you dare to speak for those who have been abandoned without <<an identity? <<By what right do you dare to speak for adopted people?  By what right too <<you purse you agenda of creating anonymous people? <<Marley Dear Marley, I have never claimed to speak for a single adopted person. <!—snippers— Let’s not forget there are many adoptees who favor Baby Safe Haven laws. A few very prominent ones are working with us here in MA. Now go ahead and go off on one of your rants, as I know you will.  :-) Jean Boy, it didn’t take you long to claim to speak for adoptees, disclaimer aside. About two paragraphs. Ron

And, I’d sure like to know how many adopted persons of the Morriseys acquaintance support safe havens.  So far we’ve got the Morriseys and Mr. Tobin  speaking for his brother. Marley – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text –

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Albeit an angry, frustrated, and often lonely one. And your solution is that death is better then what you allege is a lonely, frustrated life. Jean <<By what right do you dare to speak for those who have been abandoned without <<an identity? <<By what right do you dare to speak for adopted people?  By what right too <<you purse you agenda of creating anonymous people? <<Marley Dear Marley, I have never claimed to speak for a single adopted person.

<!—snippers— Let’s not forget there are many adoptees who favor Baby Safe Haven laws. A few very prominent ones are working with us here in MA. Now go ahead and go off on one of your rants, as I know you will.  :-) Jean

Boy, it didn’t take you long to claim to speak for adoptees, disclaimer aside. About two paragraphs. Ron

Response:

Albeit an angry, frustrated, and often lonely one. And your solution is that death is better then what you allege is a lonely, frustrated life. Jean

<<By what right do you dare to speak for those who have been abandoned without <<an identity? <<By what right do you dare to speak for adopted people?  By what right too <<you purse you agenda of creating anonymous people? <<Marley Dear Marley,   I have never claimed to speak for a single adopted person. And not for a person who was abandoned.  I only speak in favor of Baby Safe Haven laws that have saved the lives of many newborns, and will hopefully save the lives of many more.  I do not want to see another tragedy, such as the baby I buried. Marley, have you ever looked at the face of a newborn who was left out in the elements for a couple of days?  I can tell you that it’s a picture in your memory that you will never forget. If Baby Safe Haven laws can prevent another tragedy like that, I’ll continue to advocate for their positive outcome. Don’t forget that babies brought to a safe havens can be reunited with their birth mothers and fathers, and a percentage are reunited with their birth families, not always adopted.  They are also alive, tell me how that is a bad outcome? Don’t forget that if you are alive, you can find your identity, or your birth mother can come forward with it at any time.   Let’s not forget there are many adoptees who favor Baby Safe Haven laws. A few very prominent ones are working with us here in MA. Now go ahead and go off on one of your rants, as I know you will.  :-)   Jean  

Response:

Question:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – The most disturbing aspect of this particular post is the lines HAPPY BIRTHDAY DEAR SAFE HAVEN BABY MAY THERE BE MANY MORE LIKE YOU! In praise of baby abandonment and blank slatism, the conviction that talking young women into anon abandonment as a convenience is something for which we should strive. Marley Believe it or nor Marley, we consider it even more of a success that 17 pregnant women in crisis were counseled into traditional adoptions in New York last year, rather then using the safe haven option. How did you manage to persuade them to choose adoption over abandonment, was it when they approached the baby chute? Or did those 17 mothers contact you and say they intended to abandon their babies once they were born?  Your argument makes no sense. Women who abandon don’t tell people in advance. They make no plans because they are in denial of their pregnancies. Di For your edification, Di, here are some links to the Bastard Box—oops, I mean baby chute.slot, hatch, deposit box,  recycle center, receptacle–whatever you want to call it– in Pomona.  The last link is especially interesting since it has a picture of this most contemporary of identity stripping devices. Note the cathedral-like appearance, the ritualistic sacrifice motif, the meditation garden, the advertisement for Garden of Angels. Safe surrender receptacle unveiled at Pomona Valley Hospital Medical Center http://www.foryoumagazine.com/pastarticles/gardenofangels.html Explains how hatch works San Diego.com Hospital opens special baby receptacle for unwanted babies http://www.signonsandiego.com/news/state/20010921-0011-abandonedbab.html The Wolfpacket Local hospital creates program for unwanted newborns http://www.cusd.claremont.edu/www/clubs/wolfpacket/nov1601/news4.html includes picture of The Door of Hope (would I kid you?) A less sophisticated device can be found at the Thunderbird Samaritan Hospital in Glendale, AZ.   The article is in the paid archives, but here’s a summary of it: Arizona Republic, October 31, 2001 Hospital starts baby depository "Mothers who want to give up their babies, but don’t want anyone to know, can now place their infants in a baby deposit box….." "Thunderbird Nest" is located just east of the ER entrance.  A rectangular metal door opens to a sliding 3×3 foot wood box lined with a hospital-issue white blanket.  Mother can place baby in the open-topped drawer, slide it back into the wall and close the door.  Alarm sounds when metal door is opened so hospital staff can retrieve infant. "Khan said teenagers could also anonymously leave their infants outside fire stations then ring  buzzer.  If that what you’re comfortable with, do that" Unfortunately, the pictures of the "Babyklappe" in Germany are no longer available via Yahoo.  It reminded me of an old Mangel ironing machine. Marley

I forgot to add that in Pomona, the donor can pick up some literature at the Bastard Box.  Apparently that serves as counseling. Marley – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text –

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – The most disturbing aspect of this particular post is the lines HAPPY BIRTHDAY DEAR SAFE HAVEN BABY MAY THERE BE MANY MORE LIKE YOU! In praise of baby abandonment and blank slatism, the conviction that talking young women into anon abandonment as a convenience is something for which we should strive. Marley Believe it or nor Marley, we consider it even more of a success that 17 pregnant women in crisis were counseled into traditional adoptions in New York last year, rather then using the safe haven option.

How did you manage to persuade them to choose adoption over abandonment, was it when they approached the baby chute? Or did those 17 mothers contact you and say they intended to abandon their babies once they were born?  Your argument makes no sense. Women who abandon don’t tell people in advance. They make no plans because they are in denial of their pregnancies. Di   Which to us is always the – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – last option, and one that also needs to be there as a safety net. Remember that a living baby always has a past, can celebrate birthdays each year, and always has options open for reunification — as you can see in today’s Parade Magazine. Jean

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – The most disturbing aspect of this particular post is the lines HAPPY BIRTHDAY DEAR SAFE HAVEN BABY MAY THERE BE MANY MORE LIKE YOU! In praise of baby abandonment and blank slatism, the conviction that talking young women into anon abandonment as a convenience is something for which we should strive. Marley Believe it or nor Marley, we consider it even more of a success that 17 pregnant women in crisis were counseled into traditional adoptions in New York last year, rather then using the safe haven option. How did you manage to persuade them to choose adoption over abandonment, was it when they approached the baby chute? Or did those 17 mothers contact you and say they intended to abandon their babies once they were born?  Your argument makes no sense. Women who abandon don’t tell people in advance. They make no plans because they are in denial of their pregnancies. Di

For your edification, Di, here are some links to the Bastard Box—oops, I mean baby chute.slot, hatch, deposit box,  recycle center, receptacle–whatever you want to call it– in Pomona.  The last link is especially interesting since it has a picture of this most contemporary of identity stripping devices. Note the cathedral-like appearance, the ritualistic sacrifice motif, the meditation garden, the advertisement for Garden of Angels. Safe surrender receptacle unveiled at Pomona Valley Hospital Medical Center http://www.foryoumagazine.com/pastarticles/gardenofangels.html Explains how hatch works San Diego.com Hospital opens special baby receptacle for unwanted babies http://www.signonsandiego.com/news/state/20010921-0011-abandonedbab.html The Wolfpacket Local hospital creates program for unwanted newborns http://www.cusd.claremont.edu/www/clubs/wolfpacket/nov1601/news4.html includes picture of The Door of Hope (would I kid you?) A less sophisticated device can be found at the Thunderbird Samaritan Hospital in Glendale, AZ.   The article is in the paid archives, but here’s a summary of it: Arizona Republic, October 31, 2001 Hospital starts baby depository "Mothers who want to give up their babies, but don’t want anyone to know, can now place their infants in a baby deposit box….." "Thunderbird Nest" is located just east of the ER entrance.  A rectangular metal door opens to a sliding 3×3 foot wood box lined with a hospital-issue white blanket.  Mother can place baby in the open-topped drawer, slide it back into the wall and close the door.  Alarm sounds when metal door is opened so hospital staff can retrieve infant. "Khan said teenagers could also anonymously leave their infants outside fire stations then ring  buzzer.  If that what you’re comfortable with, do that" Unfortunately, the pictures of the "Babyklappe" in Germany are no longer available via Yahoo.  It reminded me of an old Mangel ironing machine. Marley

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – snip Will you all now join me in a chorus of "Happy Birthday" for a sweet little boy in IL, who was born one year ago today, and is alive because of the IL Baby SH law. HAPPY BIRTHDAY TO YOU HAPPY BIRTHDAY TO YOU HAPPY BIRTHDAY DEAR SAFE HAVEN BABY MAY THERE BE MANY MORE LIKE YOU!   Holy fuck, you are a loon! And God bless you, little baby.   And pray to God that you never need a kidney or a bone marrow transplant! Pray that you don’t suddenly drop dead of something completely preventable if only you’d had your medical history!  Pray that you don’t one day pass along a genetic timebomb to one of your own offspring – again, no medical history!

Well as the Church Lady at the Ohio hearings said, "He’ll just have to learn to live with it."  She then went on to describe HER hereditary ovarian cancer.   Not that you’d care – it’s only HWIs with no way to trace their birthfamilies that you’re interested in saving.  Once they grow up, you could care less. Ghoulagirl.

The most disturbing aspect of this particular post is the linesHAPPY BIRTHDAY DEAR SAFE HAVEN BABY MAY THERE BE MANY MORE LIKE YOU!

In praise of baby abandonment and blank slatism, the conviction that talking young women into anon abandonment as a convenience is something for which we should strive. Marley : – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – "We’re not speculating about the nature of the man.  We know the nature of the man." – George W. Bush on Saddam Hussein, 3/6/2003

Response:

The most disturbing aspect of this particular post is the lines HAPPY BIRTHDAY DEAR SAFE HAVEN BABY MAY THERE BE MANY MORE LIKE YOU!

In praise of baby abandonment and blank slatism, the conviction that talking young women into anon abandonment as a convenience is something for which we should strive. Marley Believe it or nor Marley, we consider it even more of a success that 17 pregnant women in crisis were counseled into traditional adoptions in New York last year, rather then using the safe haven option.  Which to us is always the last option, and one that also needs to be there as a safety net. Remember that a living baby always has a past, can celebrate birthdays each year, and always has options open for reunification — as you can see in today’s Parade Magazine. Jean

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – The most disturbing aspect of this particular post is the lines HAPPY BIRTHDAY DEAR SAFE HAVEN BABY MAY THERE BE MANY MORE LIKE YOU! In praise of baby abandonment and blank slatism, the conviction that talking young women into anon abandonment as a convenience is something for which we should strive. Marley Believe it or nor Marley, we consider it even more of a success that 17 pregnant women in crisis were counseled into traditional adoptions in New York last year, rather then using the safe haven option.  Which to us is always the last option, and one that also needs to be there as a safety net. Remember that a living baby always has a past, can celebrate birthdays each year, and always has options open for reunification — as you can see in today’s Parade Magazine. Jean

If one wants to discuss history, it can’t be done in a vacuum.  History begins before birth.  Baby Moses laws erase that history and context, erase the parents, and present the old fashioned clean slate with which some adopters are still enamored.  The baby’s history begins at the moment of being "saved." I still find it interesting that SH supporters deny and reject the experience of real live adopted persons, real live birth parents, real live adoptive parents, and real live advocates who work with them–all of whom oppose the laws.   And I find it appalling that you reject the voices of those who were abandoned and grew up in identity void.  Kinda like standing by while the looters ransack the Iraq National Museum. Clean slate is peculiar to the American Experience.  Go west young man, go west.  The Turner thesis and all. Each story has a Hero, a Crime, a Victim, and a Villain.  The Villain (bparent) is evil and irrational, the Hero (you and the SH gang) can’t reason with the Villain.  The Victim (baby) is innocent; and the Crime is illegal abanondonment.  But what happens to your narrative when the Victim becomes the Villain as you portray adopted persons who oppose you?  What happens when the other heroes (aparents and paps) oppose you?  What happens when the Villain (bmother) becomes the Hero(ine) in doing her duty of convenience but later comes back and seeks her own justice, thus becoming a Villain again?  And what happens when You the Hero becomes the Villain when we condemn you and your identity-stripping scheme?  What happens when the Hero  (you again!) becomes victimized by the Victim (us)  who demands recognition and retribution?  Oh, my!  Literary theory turns into real life bad practice.  Kinda like Marx turning Hegel on his head.  It’s tough, I know.  The multiplicity of it all. As a footnote, I would also point out that Tim’s program is quite unusual. Tim, in fact, admits that he has been influenced  regarding counseling and father’s rights (especially ) by Bastard Nation and Ron Morgan in particular.  In most states there is no or next to no counseling offered; no options offered.  Heck some don’t even get out a puny brochure. Dumping your baby is a consumer "choice."  And it’s  grab and run at the other end.  How, pray tell, is a cop or an EMS worker expected to counsel and offer real alternatives?  If a bleeding woman shows up with a medically frail newborn at the front door of DePelchin, whose gonna take care of them? Marley

Response:

Here’s an article about Matthew’s *public* birthday party yesterday in downtown Chicago. And how about that beautiful picture…absolutely priceless, don’t you

think? It’s a cute picture, but exploits a tragic situation.  A photo-op to push a political agenda.   I can’t imagine what the aparents were thinking in letting this little boy be used like this.  No doubt when he’s older he will be thrilled to have been marked like this–not.  As I said, ask any adopted person how they would like to be used in this way.  Ask those adopted persons who were used for similar reasons in the 1960s-1980s–lined up like trick dogs to entertain the public.  I’m reminded of Nancy Hoffman’s photo-op a few months ago during the adoption of the Baldwin Township Magic Baby which was a blatant advertisement for baby abandonment.  I can only imagine what Albee would make of this.  Abandonees as commodity, pure and simple  Oh and BTW- what a bunch of party poopers you all are… just for that, there will be no B Day cake for any of you

That’s us, all right!  Party poopers.  Kill joys. Marley Baby Bumble

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – The slow motion is the time that it will be before they turn on baby SH laws. It will be a very long time. By which time you will have had a hand in creating a new sub-class of adopted people.  Don’t expect any gratitude.

  Are you kidding me?  Those two loonies feel that the only good adopted child is a grateful, SILENT adopted child. Ghoulagirl. "We’re not speculating about the nature of the man.  We know the nature of the man."                 – George W. Bush on Saddam Hussein, 3/6/2003

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Here’s an article about Matthew’s *public* birthday party yesterday in downtown Chicago. And how about that beautiful picture…absolutely priceless, don’t you think? It’s a cute picture, but exploits a tragic situation.  A photo-op to push a political agenda.  

Kind of like those dead baby pictures. I can’t imagine what the aparents were thinking in letting this little boy be used like this.  

Oh Marley, surely you can imagine what they were thinking.  Self-aggrandizement for being "rescuing angels". No doubt when he’s older he will be thrilled to have been marked like this–not.  

Why should they care about what he thinks?  It’s their chance to publically jerk-off for their 15 minutes of fame.

Response:

snip – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -Will you all now join me in a chorus of "Happy Birthday" for a sweet little boy in IL, who was born one year ago today, and is alive because of the IL Baby SH law. HAPPY BIRTHDAY TO YOU HAPPY BIRTHDAY TO YOU HAPPY BIRTHDAY DEAR SAFE HAVEN BABY MAY THERE BE MANY MORE LIKE YOU!

  Holy fuck, you are a loon! And God bless you, little baby.

  And pray to God that you never need a kidney or a bone marrow transplant! Pray that you don’t suddenly drop dead of something completely preventable if only you’d had your medical history!  Pray that you don’t one day pass along a genetic timebomb to one of your own offspring – again, no medical history!   Not that you’d care – it’s only HWIs with no way to trace their birthfamilies that you’re interested in saving.  Once they grow up, you could care less. Ghoulagirl. "We’re not speculating about the nature of the man.  We know the nature of the man."                 – George W. Bush on Saddam Hussein, 3/6/2003

Response:

Here’s an article about Matthew’s *public* birthday party yesterday in downtown Chicago. And how about that beautiful picture…absolutely priceless, don’t you think?  Oh and BTW- what a bunch of party poopers you all are… just for that, there will be no B Day cake for any of you

Gasp! Party pooper… No birthday cake… That’s exactly what my birthmother wrote in the note pinned to my bonnet! Boohoo, rejected again… Ron – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text –

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Will somebody send Adam Pertain and the Donaldson think tank a life raft as they go sinking down to the mindless bottom of the tank itself.   Is he on a self destructive binge, or what? Nobody is paying attention to his "commentaries" that pop up occasionally. Every small town politician knows that if you have to write your own letters to the editor, you are SUNK!!!  Poor Adam cannot get a single newspaper editorial board anywhere in the country to back his position, with an editorial written by a credible newspaper editorial board or director. This includes his own former employer the Boston Globe. I’m not sure how much play EBD’s report has received.  What I do find interesting is that you get so worked up over it.  Having invested all this time promoting these laws, you scoff at the first study that comes out regarding their effectiveness. Essentially, you say, "We expect ‘x’ as a result of these laws."  The report says, "Proponents of the laws expected ‘x’.  We can’t be sure that ‘x’ is even happening, however it is evident to this panel that ‘y’ is occuring as result. Additionally, we feel that ‘y’ is NOT a good thing." Now, given your investment, one would think you would value this information given the fact that your stance is based entirely upon hypothesis.  A person who truly cared about the issue would be interested creating legislation that actually works without harmful consequences.  You offer nothing to contradict the EBD report except anecdotes regarding babies, dead and alive as political capital. Maybe he should return to his old job of restaurant reviewer. Perhaps.  On the other hand, he does a decent job of getting you all frothed up.   I know of a good French restaurant that needs a plug since so many Americans are boycotting French goods. Are you?  I think this whole boycott stuff is incredibly stupid.  I won’t give up my CdP. Jack

It reminds me of prosecutors, who to make a name for themselves and to clear the books,  railroad innocent people into prison while the serial rapist or killer continues his merry way.  Convenience, thy name is Save Haven. Marley

Response:

<<You know, I collect scandal mags from the fifties. Well, isn’t that very nice.  I guess everyone needs to have a hobby to occupy their mind.

That’s right. What do you guys do when you’re not pimping Safe Havens? – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – <<<The press is a fickle mistress, enjoy your time warming in its sun. Please, I’m looking at a raging snow and ice storm here, if you’re offering me the sun then send the tickets to Bermuda to me ASAP!! <<The press is a fickle mistress, If that’s what you’re calling the media that refuses to give a single editorial backing Adam’s position that I guess he’s getting pretty frustrated courting that fickle mistress.  It seems that he can’t get anyone to get in bed with him on his report, even his former employer the Boston Globe. Poor Adam, he just can’t seem to get any action. <<they’ll delight in recording your fall in slow motion. The slow motion is the time that it will be before they turn on baby SH laws. It will be a very long time.

Whatever. I suppose I’ve been around longer than you, and have seen flip-flops more astounding. Jean Will you all now join me in a chorus of "Happy Birthday" for a sweet little boy in IL, who was born one year ago today, and is alive because of the IL Baby SH law.

Happy Birthday, kid. When you get old enough to resent being pimped by the Baby Dump crowd, come and talk to some Bastards… Ron

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – <<You know, I collect scandal mags from the fifties. Well, isn’t that very nice.  I guess everyone needs to have a hobby to occupy their mind. That’s right. What do you guys do when you’re not pimping Safe Havens? <<<The press is a fickle mistress, enjoy your time warming in its sun. Please, I’m looking at a raging snow and ice storm here, if you’re offering me the sun then send the tickets to Bermuda to me ASAP!! <<The press is a fickle mistress, If that’s what you’re calling the media that refuses to give a single editorial backing Adam’s position that I guess he’s getting pretty frustrated courting that fickle mistress.  It seems that he can’t get anyone to get in bed with him on his report, even his former employer the Boston Globe. Poor Adam, he just can’t seem to get any action. <<they’ll delight in recording your fall in slow motion. The slow motion is the time that it will be before they turn on baby SH laws. It will be a very long time. Whatever. I suppose I’ve been around longer than you, and have seen flip-flops more astounding. Jean Will you all now join me in a chorus of "Happy Birthday" for a sweet little boy in IL, who was born one year ago today, and is alive because of the IL Baby SH law. Happy Birthday, kid. When you get old enough to resent being pimped by the Baby Dump crowd, come and talk to some Bastards… Ron

Here’s an article about Matthew’s *public* birthday party yesterday in downtown Chicago. Rockford Register-Star, April 5, 2003 1 year, 1 law, healthy baby, 2 thankful parents http://cf.rrstar.com/sendalink/emailtofriend.cfm CHICAGO–Account of Save Abandoned Babies Day in Chicago.  Review of Baby Matthew  case (no mention that the same paper had previously claimed that Matthew’s mother safe havened him because she didn’t want an open adoption). Aparents are grateful for birthmother’s "courage."  About 50 well-wishers attended birthday part at Sugar in downtown Chicago; Matthew highlighted. Click on http://www.rrstar.com/localnews/20030405-40029.shtml and go to bottom of page for picture of Matthew. I feel really bad for for Matthew.  He’s too young to understand what happened to him and how he’s being exploited now for an agenda. And  I do not blame the aparents for this appalling lack of good taste.  He is undoubtedly in a loving home, but everyone has been suckered on this one. Just ask adopted adults how they felt as kids when they status was advertised all over the newspapers. .  For decades, large adoptive families, interracial families, international adoptions all have garnered a perverse interest in the beneficiaries of adoption. No doubt this freakiization and fetishization will continue year after year.  Whatever happened to Matthews "right to privacy"? Marley

Response:

Will somebody send Adam Pertain and the Donaldson think tank a life raft as they go sinking down to the mindless bottom of the tank itself.   Is he on a self destructive binge, or what? Nobody is paying attention to his "commentaries" that pop up occasionally. Every small town politician knows that if you have to write your own letters to the editor, you are SUNK!!!  Poor Adam cannot get a single newspaper editorial board anywhere in the country to back his position, with an editorial written by a credible newspaper editorial board or director. This includes his own former employer the Boston Globe.

I’m not sure how much play EBD’s report has received.  What I do find interesting is that you get so worked up over it.  Having invested all this time promoting these laws, you scoff at the first study that comes out regarding their effectiveness. Essentially, you say, "We expect ‘x’ as a result of these laws."  The report says, "Proponents of the laws expected ‘x’.  We can’t be sure that ‘x’ is even happening, however it is evident to this panel that ‘y’ is occuring as result. Additionally, we feel that ‘y’ is NOT a good thing." Now, given your investment, one would think you would value this information given the fact that your stance is based entirely upon hypothesis.  A person who truly cared about the issue would be interested creating legislation that actually works without harmful consequences.  You offer nothing to contradict the EBD report except anecdotes regarding babies, dead and alive as political capital. Maybe he should return to his old job of restaurant reviewer.

Perhaps.  On the other hand, he does a decent job of getting you all frothed up.   I know of a good French restaurant that needs a plug since so many Americans are boycotting French goods.

Are you?  I think this whole boycott stuff is incredibly stupid.  I won’t give up my CdP. Jack

Response:

Here’s an article about Matthew’s *public* birthday party yesterday in

downtown Chicago. And how about that beautiful picture…absolutely priceless, don’t you think?    Oh and BTW- what a bunch of party poopers you all are… just for that, there will be no B Day cake for any of you

Response:

The slow motion is the time that it will be before they turn on baby SH laws. It will be a very long time.

By which time you will have had a hand in creating a new sub-class of adopted people.  Don’t expect any gratitude. Will you all now join me in a chorus of "Happy Birthday" for a sweet little boy in IL, who was born one year ago today, and is alive because of the IL Baby SH law.

Hogwash.  There is absolutely nothing to suggest that the child in question would have been in any danger.  In fact, from what I understand, the "safe haven" was used simply as a convenient alternative to traditional means of relinquishment.  Additionally, I’ve read more than once, that part of the appeal of "safe havens" are to simplify the process so people considering relinquishment don’t have to deal with time consuming and complicated paperwork.   Had such a law not existed, the child would not only be alive and well, but have a possibility of discovering his heritage in the future. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – HAPPY BIRTHDAY TO YOU HAPPY BIRTHDAY TO YOU HAPPY BIRTHDAY DEAR SAFE HAVEN BABY MAY THERE BE MANY MORE LIKE YOU!

Interesting.  "May there be many more like you," suggests that your only concern is pushing babies through these programs and effectively replacing identities.  The fact that you are possibly doing more harm than good doesn’t occur to you.  You’re wallowing in the rhetoric that every child "safe havened" is a life saved even though there is plenty of evidence that controverts this. Speaking of lunatic fringe, you have an amazing propensity to objectify these kids (see: "Happy birthday, safe haven baby")  It’s easy.  Their identity has been erased and they simply become political currency.  It’s fascinating because one of the common symptoms in abandonment and infanticide is objectification of the infant.  Is this a value you wish to promote? Jack

Response:

<<Apparently nobody <<"From what I know, <<but it certainly appears that that something is rotten in Rockford. <<I’ve seen several references <<I don’t know if this is a coincidence or not, but Dear Marley, That’s five straws that you grasped at, cut and pasted above, and contorted to seem as if the was some kind of conspiracy against somebody, somewhere, somehow.

What are you talking about Jean?  I did not cut anything from your initital post, and I typed in a quote from a lawyer for the state of Illionis.  You like to say you deal in facts,  so address this fact.  The lawyer says as far as she understands the mother had rejected an open adoption.  That leaves other alternatives, and there is no mention of those alternatives were discussed with the mother.  Women who consider adoption are not going to kill their babies, no matter what you say, unless they are psychotic. You’re the one who talks about conspiracy.  I’m simply talking about facts as stated.  Do you deny the fact that Bill Pierce has said that SH is a reponse to open records?  Do you deny the fact that Tom Atwood says that SH is a response to open records?  Do you deny the fact that Elizabeth Coulson says that SH is a response to open adoption? Not "apparently" but certainly I do "know" that something was beautiful, not "rotten," in Rockford yesterday.  A beautiful baby boy is alive, the Mum utilized a SH law, as so many others have due to various reasons. These beautiful babies will grow up to maybe join your group someday, or any other group they decide to for their "references".

And quite simply fry you for what you have done to them–denied them any chance of identity recovery.    I can only imagine your shock if you were talk to adopted adults who were abandoned as children who think that SH are reprehensible. Our hope was that BN could some day disband when our work was done, but as long as SH is in place, we carry on.  You real need to see what the Xs have to say about do-gooding dumpers. It’s no "coincidence" that Adam Pertman, a former newspaper man, has not gotten any editorial support from a single newspaper anywhere in the country after releasing what he calls a "report," but we have gotten over 25 in MA alone, with promises of many more to come. Good try Marley, but no cigar. Regards, Jean

What’s this deal about "former newspaper man"  Is there something wrong with being a journalist–especially one who was nominated for a Pulitzer for his adoption articles and has written the very pro-adoption book Adoption Nation?  Or is adoption only good when it’s by your standards? Marley – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text –

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – <<You know, I collect scandal mags from the fifties. Well, isn’t that very nice.  I guess everyone needs to have a hobby to occupy their mind. <<<The press is a fickle mistress, enjoy your time warming in its sun. Please, I’m looking at a raging snow and ice storm here, if you’re offering me the sun then send the tickets to Bermuda to me ASAP!! <<The press is a fickle mistress, If that’s what you’re calling the media that refuses to give a single editorial backing Adam’s position that I guess he’s getting pretty frustrated courting that fickle mistress.  It seems that he can’t get anyone to get in bed with him on his report, even his former employer the Boston Globe. Poor Adam, he just can’t seem to get any action. <<they’ll delight in recording your fall in slow motion. The slow motion is the time that it will be before they turn on baby SH laws. It will be a very long time. Jean Will you all now join me in a chorus of "Happy Birthday" for a sweet little boy in IL, who was born one year ago today, and is alive because of the IL Baby SH law. HAPPY BIRTHDAY TO YOU HAPPY BIRTHDAY TO YOU HAPPY BIRTHDAY DEAR SAFE HAVEN BABY MAY THERE BE MANY MORE LIKE YOU! And God bless you, little baby.

Funny thing, Jean.  According to the April 11, 2002, edition of the Rockford Register-Star, April 11, 2002, the only thing Matthew was saved from was a best practice adoption.  According to Cheryl Cesario, attorney for the Department of Children and Family Services, "From what I know, she [mother] had looked into an open adoption but had change her mind.  She really wanted the anonymity." Apparently nobody bothered to tell the mother about closed adoptions and sealed records.   The Rockford hospital has an aggressive SH program.  Since SH is a big fat secret, nobody knows what really happened, but it certainly appears that that something is rotten in Rockford. In the last couple weeks I’ve seen several references to baby dumping as a response not only to open records but to OPEN ADOPTION, one coming from Illinois SH sponsor Elizabeth Coulson.  I don’t know if this is a coincidence or not, but if it’s not a coincidence, then the whole agenda becomes more focused. Marley

Response:

You hit it, Ron. I expect to see E. Howard Hunt crawl out of the muck soon. I’m at a loss to understand what causes this type of mentality in AdoptionLand.  It’s beyond Piercian. Marley

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – You know, I collect scandal mags from the fifties. You really have a flair for Confidential/Hush Hush journalism. Blind items, tying your subject to other, totally unrelated, unpopular figures or causes, the same tone of condescension. Except that Confidential was tarring people as fairies, reds, pinkos, and horror of horrors, race mixers. The press is a fickle mistress, enjoy your time warming in its sun. When they tire of gazing up at you on your pedestal, they’ll delight in recording your fall in slow motion. Ron I realize you don’t as a rule reply to my posts, but fuck it, it’s fun replying to yours. Will somebody send Adam Pertain and the Donaldson think tank a life raft as they go sinking down to the mindless bottom of the tank itself.   Is he on a self destructive binge, or what? Nobody is paying attention to his "commentaries" that pop up occasionally. Every small town politician knows that if you have to write your own letters to the editor, you are SUNK!!!  Poor Adam cannot get a single newspaper editorial board anywhere in the country to back his position, with an editorial written by a credible newspaper editorial board or director. This includes his own former employer the Boston Globe. Maybe he should return to his old job of restaurant reviewer.  I know of a good French restaurant that needs a plug since so many Americans are boycotting French goods. Bon apetit!  Adam, Jean Christian Science Monitor http://www.csmonitor.com/2003/0404/p11s01-coop.html "These well-intentioned laws have spread so rapidly (all in the past three years) because they promise an intuitively appealing, easy fix. But complex social problems are rarely resolved through simple, feel-good solutions. So it should come as no surprise that an extensive new study by the Evan B. Donaldson Adoption Institute in New York not only concludes that there is no evidence the safe haven statutes are working, but also finds that they are causing serious unintended consequences."

Response:

<<You know, I collect scandal mags from the fifties. Well, isn’t that very nice.  I guess everyone needs to have a hobby to occupy their mind. <<<The press is a fickle mistress, enjoy your time warming in its sun. Please, I’m looking at a raging snow and ice storm here, if you’re offering me the sun then send the tickets to Bermuda to me ASAP!! <<The press is a fickle mistress, If that’s what you’re calling the media that refuses to give a single editorial backing Adam’s position that I guess he’s getting pretty frustrated courting that fickle mistress.  It seems that he can’t get anyone to get in bed with him on his report, even his former employer the Boston Globe. Poor Adam, he just can’t seem to get any action. <<they’ll delight in recording your fall in slow motion. The slow motion is the time that it will be before they turn on baby SH laws. It will be a very long time. Jean Will you all now join me in a chorus of "Happy Birthday" for a sweet little boy in IL, who was born one year ago today, and is alive because of the IL Baby SH law. HAPPY BIRTHDAY TO YOU HAPPY BIRTHDAY TO YOU HAPPY BIRTHDAY DEAR SAFE HAVEN BABY MAY THERE BE MANY MORE LIKE YOU! And God bless you, little baby.

Response:

Top Posting:  You know, Jean, what I can’t understand is your family’s hysteria over a bill that according to you is a slam dunk.  I mean, why exercise yourself over something that’s a given–  something that all but the most "deranged"  support?  The ad hominim attacks on those stating an opposite view is disturbing to put it mildly.  Are you control freaks or something?   It’s highly unprofessional. I’ve been involved in many state Baby Moses campaigns, and I’ve never seen anything like the way the Morrisesys of Massachusetts carry on.  Politics as usual is about stating your case,  lining up committee chair support for your case, making backroom deals, door to door lobbying, generating newspaper commentary, and a lot of other mundane tasks, and then (as Ron pointed out) laying back with a couple martinis with your worse enemy.  Laws pass or fail out of expediency.  All this teeth grinding and weeping is really odd behavior for the legislatively secure (or insecure for that matter), unless you just plan to wear down everybody with insults and patronizing.  You have, much to your, dishonor, introduced the politics of intimidation into adoption discourse, and it’s ugly. Your contention that no editorial board in the country agrees with us is absurd.  As  you know both the Manchester Union Leader and Foster’s Daily Democrat in New Hampshire editorialized against *your* NH bill.  The Bloomington Pantagraph, Denver Rocky Mountain News, Hartford Courant, Palm Beach Post, and Pittsburgh Post Gazette have also editorialized against SH. I have about 26 pages of quotes from politicians, newspapers, and adoption and child welfare advocates from across the political spectrum who oppose SH.  Some of the strongest  statements come  from traditional conservatives, neocons, and evangelical Christians. Here’s a very shot list of prominent child welfare and adoption advocates who oppose:  Howard Davidson,  ABA Center on Children and Laws; Joan Hollinger,  USC-Berkeley; John Krall, National Abandoned Infants Resource Center;  Patrick Murphy, Public Guardian, Cook county, Illinois;  Donna Tubach-Davis, Child Saving Institute, Nebraska;  and Janis Weaver, Adoption Law Center, Berkeley (and a lot more). And good grief.  Holt International, the pioneer in international adoption, that has placed thousands of abandoned babies, is opposed. The Evan B. Donaldson Institute is a highly respected think tank, and your dismissal of it brings to question just what you know about adoption to start with.  And before you say it, I have disagreed with EBD on issues, but…so what?  I don’t dismiss it as some sort of hack operation.  Your provincial comparison of EBD to France says it all. Marley

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Will somebody send Adam Pertain and the Donaldson think tank a life raft as they go sinking down to the mindless bottom of the tank itself.   Is he on a self destructive binge, or what? Nobody is paying attention to his "commentaries" that pop up occasionally. Every small town politician knows that if you have to write your own letters to the editor, you are SUNK!!!  Poor Adam cannot get a single newspaper editorial board anywhere in the country to back his position, with an editorial written by a credible newspaper editorial board or director. This includes his own former employer the Boston Globe. Maybe he should return to his old job of restaurant reviewer.  I know of a good French restaurant that needs a plug since so many Americans are boycotting French goods. Bon apetit!  Adam, Jean Christian Science Monitor http://www.csmonitor.com/2003/0404/p11s01-coop.html "These well-intentioned laws have spread so rapidly (all in the past three years) because they promise an intuitively appealing, easy fix. But complex social problems are rarely resolved through simple, feel-good solutions. So it should come as no surprise that an extensive new study by the Evan B. Donaldson Adoption Institute in New York not only concludes that there is no evidence the safe haven statutes are working, but also finds that they are causing serious unintended consequences."

Response:

<<Apparently nobody <<"From what I know, <<but it certainly appears that that something is rotten in Rockford. <<I’ve seen several references <<I don’t know if this is a coincidence or not, but Dear Marley, That’s five straws that you grasped at, cut and pasted above, and contorted to seem as if the was some kind of conspiracy against somebody, somewhere, somehow. Not "apparently" but certainly I do "know" that something was beautiful, not "rotten," in Rockford yesterday.  A beautiful baby boy is alive, the Mum utilized a SH law, as so many others have due to various reasons. These beautiful babies will grow up to maybe join your group someday, or any other group they decide to for their "references". It’s no "coincidence" that Adam Pertman, a former newspaper man, has not gotten any editorial support from a single newspaper anywhere in the country after releasing what he calls a "report," but we have gotten over 25 in MA alone, with promises of many more to come. Good try Marley, but no cigar. Regards, Jean

Response:

You know, I collect scandal mags from the fifties. You really have a flair for Confidential/Hush Hush journalism. Blind items, tying your subject to other, totally unrelated, unpopular figures or causes, the same tone of condescension. Except that Confidential was tarring people as fairies, reds, pinkos, and horror of horrors, race mixers. The press is a fickle mistress, enjoy your time warming in its sun. When they tire of gazing up at you on your pedestal, they’ll delight in recording your fall in slow motion. Ron I realize you don’t as a rule reply to my posts, but fuck it, it’s fun replying to yours.

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Will somebody send Adam Pertain and the Donaldson think tank a life raft as they go sinking down to the mindless bottom of the tank itself.   Is he on a self destructive binge, or what? Nobody is paying attention to his "commentaries" that pop up occasionally. Every small town politician knows that if you have to write your own letters to the editor, you are SUNK!!!  Poor Adam cannot get a single newspaper editorial board anywhere in the country to back his position, with an editorial written by a credible newspaper editorial board or director. This includes his own former employer the Boston Globe. Maybe he should return to his old job of restaurant reviewer.  I know of a good French restaurant that needs a plug since so many Americans are boycotting French goods. Bon apetit!  Adam, Jean Christian Science Monitor http://www.csmonitor.com/2003/0404/p11s01-coop.html "These well-intentioned laws have spread so rapidly (all in the past three years) because they promise an intuitively appealing, easy fix. But complex social problems are rarely resolved through simple, feel-good solutions. So it should come as no surprise that an extensive new study by the Evan B. Donaldson Adoption Institute in New York not only concludes that there is no evidence the safe haven statutes are working, but also finds that they are causing serious unintended consequences."

Response:

Will somebody send Adam Pertain and the Donaldson think tank a life raft as they go sinking down to the mindless bottom of the tank itself.   Is he on a self destructive binge, or what? Nobody is paying attention to his "commentaries" that pop up occasionally. Every small town politician knows that if you have to write your own letters to the editor, you are SUNK!!!  Poor Adam cannot get a single newspaper editorial board anywhere in the country to back his position, with an editorial written by a credible newspaper editorial board or director. This includes his own former employer the Boston Globe. Maybe he should return to his old job of restaurant reviewer.  I know of a good French restaurant that needs a plug since so many Americans are boycotting French goods. Bon apetit!  Adam, Jean Christian Science Monitor http://www.csmonitor.com/2003/0404/p11s01-coop.html "These well-intentioned laws have spread so rapidly (all in the past three years) because they promise an intuitively appealing, easy fix. But complex social problems are rarely resolved through simple, feel-good solutions. So it should come as no surprise that an extensive new study by the Evan B. Donaldson Adoption Institute in New York not only concludes that there is no evidence the safe haven statutes are working, but also finds that they are causing serious unintended consequences."

Response:

Question:

Are you seriously suggesting keeping dirty clothes from a third world country? The child may have a natural immunity to assorted "bugs" now, but you don’t, and after a few years the child’s immunity may be lost. If you must keep old clothes, at least make sure they are properly washed and maybe fumigated. The Black Death, in Britain, is said to have come into the country in old clothes. (It was carried by fleas that bite infected black rats and humans). After all, one should always wash underwear before use if it comes from a third world country, even if bought new.  Geopelia

Flea from the wrath to come! Rh. ‘Here comes Ali’s camel in his filthy cotton shorts’ Bonzo Dog Band

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – <snip It’s the kid they should be testing for TB, Aids etc, not the clothes. Before or after? Do you know *anything* about intercountry adoption? You seemed to take issue with the idea that anyone would bring home the child’s original clothes because they would be unhygienic. And didn’t you say the following about NEW clothes that were manufactured in a poor country: "Washing underwear – the most important reason is that you don’t know if the people who have sewn and handled it, often in unhygenic conditions, have any skin diseases etc." And this: "If you can’t drink the water in a poor country, or eat their food, surely you should wash their clothes?" You have very strange ideas, indeed. Helen You are the strange one, I’m simply concerned about cleanliness, comfort and wearability.

And what, pray, has any of this got to do with adopting a child from overseas? Helen – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Geopelia Geopelia

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – <snip  But also I have found third world bras especially are full of some kind of material stiffening which needs washing out, or it is very scratchy. Particularly when there is nothing to hold up. I wouldn’t buy Indonesian underwear again, the elastic is of very poor quality and soon needs replacing. (This is not the right newsgroup to talk about the "other options"!) D’you know something? – you sound like someone playing the part of a drag queen. (A *real* one wouldn’t be so crass) ‘Stupid eejit’ comes to mind, but that is rather too mild…. *Feck off* is probably more appropriate. Helen Oh dear, and all I was doing was pointing out some elementary hygiene! Nothing "elementary" about your descriptions of the quality of elastic in their underwear and the scratchiness of their bras, just ignorance – and your idea of "hygiene" causes me a slight concern that you might suffer from an OCD.  If you can’t drink the water in a poor country, or eat their food, surely you should wash their clothes? I have drunk water all over the place – using common sense, of course – and have "eaten their food" with no ill effects. Why on Earth should I "wash their clothes"? Countries may be poor but their people are not uncivilised – far from it. You might learn a considerable amount from them if you took your head out of your underwear.  Children adopted from these countries would surely have a health check for endemic diseases – T.B., scabies, Aids etc? For a start, you are more likely to contract TB from travelling in a plane than by wearing clothes that were manufactured in another country. To the best of my knowledge, scabies *itself* is not a *disease* per se – it is a *mite* that burrows into the skin, causing intense itching. I could be wrong, but I don’t think it lives too long without a host. AIDs is a disease of the immune system, caused by infection with the retrovirus HIV. It is not transmitted by wearing clothes manufactured *anywhere*. HIV is transmitted by particular contact with infected blood or body fluids. It doesn’t survive more than a few hours outside the body so the idea that you can get it from clothing manufactured in another country is simply bizarre. So why take the risk of keeping unwashed clothes? The "risk" is all in your tiny little head. <snip It’s the kid they should be testing for TB, Aids etc, not the clothes. Before or after? Do you know *anything* about intercountry adoption? You seemed to take issue with the idea that anyone would bring home the child’s original clothes because they would be unhygienic. And didn’t you say the following about NEW clothes that were manufactured in a poor country: "Washing underwear – the most important reason is that you don’t know if the people who have sewn and handled it, often in unhygenic conditions, have any skin diseases etc." And this: "If you can’t drink the water in a poor country, or eat their food, surely you should wash their clothes?" You have very strange ideas, indeed. Helen

You are the strange one, I’m simply concerned about cleanliness, comfort and wearability. Geopelia – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Geopelia

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -

<snip – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text –  But also I have found third world bras especially are full of some kind of material stiffening which needs washing out, or it is very scratchy. Particularly when there is nothing to hold up. I wouldn’t buy Indonesian underwear again, the elastic is of very poor quality and soon needs replacing. (This is not the right newsgroup to talk about the "other options"!) D’you know something? – you sound like someone playing the part of a drag queen. (A *real* one wouldn’t be so crass) ‘Stupid eejit’ comes to mind, but that is rather too mild…. *Feck off* is probably more appropriate. Helen Oh dear, and all I was doing was pointing out some elementary hygiene! Nothing "elementary" about your descriptions of the quality of elastic in their underwear and the scratchiness of their bras, just ignorance – and your idea of "hygiene" causes me a slight concern that you might suffer from an OCD.  If you can’t drink the water in a poor country, or eat their food, surely you should wash their clothes? I have drunk water all over the place – using common sense, of course – and have "eaten their food" with no ill effects. Why on Earth should I "wash their clothes"? Countries may be poor but their people are not uncivilised – far from it. You might learn a considerable amount from them if you took your head out of your underwear.  Children adopted from these countries would surely have a health check for endemic diseases – T.B., scabies, Aids etc? For a start, you are more likely to contract TB from travelling in a plane than by wearing clothes that were manufactured in another country. To the best of my knowledge, scabies *itself* is not a *disease* per se – it is a *mite* that burrows into the skin, causing intense itching. I could be wrong, but I don’t think it lives too long without a host. AIDs is a disease of the immune system, caused by infection with the retrovirus HIV. It is not transmitted by wearing clothes manufactured *anywhere*. HIV is transmitted by particular contact with infected blood or body fluids. It doesn’t survive more than a few hours outside the body so the idea that you can get it from clothing manufactured in another country is simply bizarre. So why take the risk of keeping unwashed clothes? The "risk" is all in your tiny little head. <snip It’s the kid they should be testing for TB, Aids etc, not the clothes.

Before or after? Do you know *anything* about intercountry adoption? You seemed to take issue with the idea that anyone would bring home the child’s original clothes because they would be unhygienic. And didn’t you say the following about NEW clothes that were manufactured in a poor country: "Washing underwear – the most important reason is that you don’t know if the people who have sewn and handled it, often in unhygenic conditions, have any skin diseases etc." And this: "If you can’t drink the water in a poor country, or eat their food, surely you should wash their clothes?" You have very strange ideas, indeed. Helen – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Geopelia

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – And what is the reason "one should always wash underwear before use if it comes from a third world country..?" Finally – I was puzzled by the addition of "… even if bought new." What other options are there?  Used undies? Washing underwear – the most important reason is that you don’t know if the people who have sewn and handled it, often in unhygenic conditions, have any skin diseases etc. Would you EVER get a grip? What a load of shite, if you don’t mind my vulgarity.  But also I have found third world bras especially are full of some kind of material stiffening which needs washing out, or it is very scratchy. Particularly when there is nothing to hold up. I wouldn’t buy Indonesian underwear again, the elastic is of very poor quality and soon needs replacing. (This is not the right newsgroup to talk about the "other options"!) D’you know something? – you sound like someone playing the part of a drag queen. (A *real* one wouldn’t be so crass) ‘Stupid eejit’ comes to mind, but that is rather too mild…. *Feck off* is probably more appropriate. Helen Oh dear, and all I was doing was pointing out some elementary hygiene! Nothing "elementary" about your descriptions of the quality of elastic in their underwear and the scratchiness of their bras, just ignorance – and your idea of "hygiene" causes me a slight concern that you might suffer from an OCD.  If you can’t drink the water in a poor country, or eat their food, surely you should wash their clothes? I have drunk water all over the place – using common sense, of course – and have "eaten their food" with no ill effects. Why on Earth should I "wash their clothes"? Countries may be poor but their people are not uncivilised – far from it. You might learn a considerable amount from them if you took your head out of your underwear.  Children adopted from these countries would surely have a health check for endemic diseases – T.B., scabies, Aids etc? For a start, you are more likely to contract TB from travelling in a plane than by wearing clothes that were manufactured in another country. To the best of my knowledge, scabies *itself* is not a *disease* per se – it is a *mite* that burrows into the skin, causing intense itching. I could be wrong, but I don’t think it lives too long without a host. AIDs is a disease of the immune system, caused by infection with the retrovirus HIV. It is not transmitted by wearing clothes manufactured *anywhere*. HIV is transmitted by particular contact with infected blood or body fluids. It doesn’t survive more than a few hours outside the body so the idea that you can get it from clothing manufactured in another country is simply bizarre. So why take the risk of keeping unwashed clothes? The "risk" is all in your tiny little head.  What have drag queens got to do with anything? Your seeming obsession with aspects of female underwear just caused a thought to flit across my mind – don’t worry, it is of no consequence at all. (Should they adopt children – now there’s a thought!) Why not, if they are assessed as being suitable parenting material? You won’t get me in makeup and stilettos, and their fishnet stockings wouldn’t even keep out mozzie bites. I’ll stick to T shirts, shorts and gumboots, thank you! Yeah – well T shirts and shorts won’t keep the mozzies away. You might be better off dressed head to toe in good quality Indian cotton. Helen

It’s the kid they should be testing for TB, Aids etc, not the clothes. Geopelia – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Geopelia Geopelia Julia More information at http://www.washtimes.com/familytimes/20021230-91551250.htm Books &#8212;      "International Adoption Travel Journal," by Mary Ebejer Petertyl, Folio One Publishing, 2002. This book helps adoptive parents prepare a memento for their children by supplying spaces for itineraries, a daily travel journal, destinations and more.      "Adoption Nation: How the Adoption Revolution is Transforming America," by Adam Pertman, 2000. This Book of the Year Award-winner provides insights into the pleasures and perils of adoption and includes a section on international adoption. Associations &#8212;      Evan B. Donaldson Adoption Institute, 120 Wall St., New York, NY 10005. Phone: 212/269-5080. Web site:

www.adoptioninstitute.org. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – The institute is a national, nonprofit organization devoted to improving adoption policy and practices by improving the quality of information about adoption.      National Adoption Information Clearinghouse, 330 C St. SW, Washington, D.C. 20447. Phone: 703/352-3488. Web site: www.calib.com/naic. This organization, part of the Department of Health and Human Services, is a comprehensive resource on all aspects of adoption. Online &#8212;      AdoptionTravel.com, a for-profit site sponsored by Folio One Publishing, contains tips, travel articles, adoption links and travel resources for those embarking on an overseas trip for adoption.      InternationalAdoption.org is a vast for-profit site with information and resources on topics such as immigration laws, adoption benefits and how to secure a home study.

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – And what is the reason "one should always wash underwear before use if it comes from a third world country..?" Finally – I was puzzled by the addition of "… even if bought new." What other options are there?  Used undies? Washing underwear – the most important reason is that you don’t know if the people who have sewn and handled it, often in unhygenic conditions, have any skin diseases etc. Would you EVER get a grip? What a load of shite, if you don’t mind my vulgarity.  But also I have found third world bras especially are full of some kind of material stiffening which needs washing out, or it is very scratchy. Particularly when there is nothing to hold up. I wouldn’t buy Indonesian underwear again, the elastic is of very poor quality and soon needs replacing. (This is not the right newsgroup to talk about the "other options"!) D’you know something? – you sound like someone playing the part of a drag queen. (A *real* one wouldn’t be so crass) ‘Stupid eejit’ comes to mind, but that is rather too mild…. *Feck off* is probably more appropriate. Helen Oh dear, and all I was doing was pointing out some elementary hygiene!

Nothing "elementary" about your descriptions of the quality of elastic in their underwear and the scratchiness of their bras, just ignorance – and your idea of "hygiene" causes me a slight concern that you might suffer from an OCD.  If you can’t drink the water in a poor country, or eat their food, surely you should wash their clothes?

I have drunk water all over the place – using common sense, of course – and have "eaten their food" with no ill effects. Why on Earth should I "wash their clothes"? Countries may be poor but their people are not uncivilised – far from it. You might learn a considerable amount from them if you took your head out of your underwear.  Children adopted from these countries would surely have a health check for endemic diseases – T.B., scabies, Aids etc?

For a start, you are more likely to contract TB from travelling in a plane than by wearing clothes that were manufactured in another country. To the best of my knowledge, scabies *itself* is not a *disease* per se – it is a *mite* that burrows into the skin, causing intense itching. I could be wrong, but I don’t think it lives too long without a host. AIDs is a disease of the immune system, caused by infection with the retrovirus HIV. It is not transmitted by wearing clothes manufactured *anywhere*. HIV is transmitted by particular contact with infected blood or body fluids. It doesn’t survive more than a few hours outside the body so the idea that you can get it from clothing manufactured in another country is simply bizarre. So why take the risk of keeping unwashed clothes?

The "risk" is all in your tiny little head.  What have drag queens got to do with anything?

Your seeming obsession with aspects of female underwear just caused a thought to flit across my mind – don’t worry, it is of no consequence at all. (Should they adopt children – now there’s a thought!)

Why not, if they are assessed as being suitable parenting material? You won’t get me in makeup and stilettos, and their fishnet stockings wouldn’t even keep out mozzie bites. I’ll stick to T shirts, shorts and gumboots, thank you!

Yeah – well T shirts and shorts won’t keep the mozzies away. You might be better off dressed head to toe in good quality Indian cotton. Helen Geopelia – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Geopelia Julia More information at http://www.washtimes.com/familytimes/20021230-91551250.htm Books &#8212;      "International Adoption Travel Journal," by Mary Ebejer Petertyl, Folio One Publishing, 2002. This book helps adoptive parents prepare a memento for their children by supplying spaces for itineraries, a daily travel journal, destinations and more.      "Adoption Nation: How the Adoption Revolution is Transforming America," by Adam Pertman, 2000. This Book of the Year Award-winner provides insights into the pleasures and perils of adoption and includes a section on international adoption. Associations &#8212;      Evan B. Donaldson Adoption Institute, 120 Wall St., New York, NY 10005. Phone: 212/269-5080. Web site: www.adoptioninstitute.org. The institute is a national, nonprofit organization devoted to improving adoption policy and practices by improving the quality of information about adoption.      National Adoption Information Clearinghouse, 330 C St. SW, Washington, D.C. 20447. Phone: 703/352-3488. Web site: www.calib.com/naic. This organization, part of the Department of Health and Human Services, is a comprehensive resource on all aspects of adoption. Online &#8212;      AdoptionTravel.com, a for-profit site sponsored by Folio One Publishing, contains tips, travel articles, adoption links and travel resources for those embarking on an overseas trip for adoption.      InternationalAdoption.org is a vast for-profit site with information and resources on topics such as immigration laws, adoption benefits and how to secure a home study.

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – And what is the reason "one should always wash underwear before use if it comes from a third world country..?" Finally – I was puzzled by the addition of "… even if bought new." What other options are there?  Used undies? Washing underwear – the most important reason is that you don’t know if the people who have sewn and handled it, often in unhygenic conditions, have any skin diseases etc. Would you EVER get a grip? What a load of shite, if you don’t mind my vulgarity.  But also I have found third world bras especially are full of some kind of material stiffening which needs washing out, or it is very scratchy. Particularly when there is nothing to hold up. I wouldn’t buy Indonesian underwear again, the elastic is of very poor quality and soon needs replacing. (This is not the right newsgroup to talk about the "other options"!) D’you know something? – you sound like someone playing the part of a drag queen. (A *real* one wouldn’t be so crass) ‘Stupid eejit’ comes to mind, but that is rather too mild…. *Feck off* is probably more appropriate. Helen

Oh dear, and all I was doing was pointing out some elementary hygiene! If you can’t drink the water in a poor country, or eat their food, surely you should wash their clothes? Children adopted from these countries would surely have a health check for endemic diseases – T.B., scabies, Aids etc? So why take the risk of keeping unwashed clothes? What have drag queens got to do with anything? (Should they adopt children – now there’s a thought!) You won’t get me in makeup and stilettos, and their fishnet stockings wouldn’t even keep out mozzie bites. I’ll stick to T shirts, shorts and gumboots, thank you!  Geopelia – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Geopelia Julia More information at http://www.washtimes.com/familytimes/20021230-91551250.htm Books &#8212;      "International Adoption Travel Journal," by Mary Ebejer Petertyl, Folio One Publishing, 2002. This book helps adoptive parents prepare a memento for their children by supplying spaces for itineraries, a daily travel journal, destinations and more.      "Adoption Nation: How the Adoption Revolution is Transforming America," by Adam Pertman, 2000. This Book of the Year Award-winner provides insights into the pleasures and perils of adoption and includes a section on international adoption. Associations &#8212;      Evan B. Donaldson Adoption Institute, 120 Wall St., New York, NY 10005. Phone: 212/269-5080. Web site: www.adoptioninstitute.org. The institute is a national, nonprofit organization devoted to improving adoption policy and practices by improving the quality of information about adoption.      National Adoption Information Clearinghouse, 330 C St. SW, Washington, D.C. 20447. Phone: 703/352-3488. Web site: www.calib.com/naic. This organization, part of the Department of Health and Human Services, is a comprehensive resource on all aspects of adoption. Online &#8212;      AdoptionTravel.com, a for-profit site sponsored by Folio One Publishing, contains tips, travel articles, adoption links and travel resources for those embarking on an overseas trip for adoption.      InternationalAdoption.org is a vast for-profit site with information and resources on topics such as immigration laws, adoption benefits and how to secure a home study.

Response:

<snip – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Are you seriously suggesting keeping dirty clothes from a third world country? The child may have a natural immunity to assorted "bugs" now, but you don’t, and after a few years the child’s immunity may be lost. If you must keep old clothes, at least make sure they are properly washed and maybe fumigated. The Black Death, in Britain, is said to have come into the country in old clothes. (It was carried by fleas that bite infected black rats and humans). After all, one should always wash underwear before use if it comes from a third world country, even if bought new.  Geopelia I think it was pretty good advice, and we kept our kids clothes as were without any need to fumigate anything (the kids needed fumigating more than their clothes but that is another story). And what is the reason "one should always wash underwear before use if it comes from a third world country..?" Finally – I was puzzled by the addition of "… even if bought new." What other options are there?  Used undies? Washing underwear – the most important reason is that you don’t know if the people who have sewn and handled it, often in unhygenic conditions, have any skin diseases etc. Do you autoclave them before use just to make sure? IMO this level of paranoia over possible contagion is nonsensical.  If you are this concerned about clothing, it would be interesting to see how you would manage actual travel in developing countries.

In days of yore, long, long, *long* ago, when I travelled quite a lot – including to various parts of India – I never had any problems with insects, except in the United States! I was almost *eaten alive* by mosquitoes in Tampa, Florida, and I still have some marks on my legs, as souvenirs. The MOST rats I ever saw in one place was in the port area of New Orleans. **Millions** of them, packed shoulder to shoulder, all looking at me and squeaking. Yes, I too thought of bubonic plague… If we followed geopelia’s reasoning we would have to treat every stitch that we buy as second-hand clothes, because so much – and even so-called designer labels – are manufactured in third-world sweatshops. An abiding memory I have of India is the absolute cleanliness of even the poorest of the poor. Helen – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Julia But also I have found third world bras especially are full of some kind of material stiffening which needs washing out, or it is very scratchy. I wouldn’t buy Indonesian underwear again, the elastic is of very poor quality and soon needs replacing. (This is not the right newsgroup to talk about the "other options"!) Geopelia Julia More information at http://www.washtimes.com/familytimes/20021230-91551250.htm Books &#8212;      "International Adoption Travel Journal," by Mary Ebejer Petertyl, Folio One Publishing, 2002. This book helps adoptive parents prepare a memento for their children by supplying spaces for itineraries, a daily travel journal, destinations and more.      "Adoption Nation: How the Adoption Revolution is Transforming America," by Adam Pertman, 2000. This Book of the Year Award-winner provides insights into the pleasures and perils of adoption and includes a section on international adoption. Associations &#8212;      Evan B. Donaldson Adoption Institute, 120 Wall St., New York, NY 10005. Phone: 212/269-5080. Web site: www.adoptioninstitute.org. The institute is a national, nonprofit organization devoted to improving adoption policy and practices by improving the quality of information about adoption.      National Adoption Information Clearinghouse, 330 C St. SW, Washington, D.C. 20447. Phone: 703/352-3488. Web site: www.calib.com/naic. This organization, part of the Department of Health and Human Services, is a comprehensive resource on all aspects of adoption. Online &#8212;      AdoptionTravel.com, a for-profit site sponsored by Folio One Publishing, contains tips, travel articles, adoption links and travel resources for those embarking on an overseas trip for adoption.      InternationalAdoption.org is a vast for-profit site with information and resources on topics such as immigration laws, adoption benefits and how to secure a home study.

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Adoption odyessy In the world of adoption travel, flexibility is key and preparation is just about everything else: Choose scrupulous agencies, sharpen skills of consumerism, learn about host countries and listen to the words of wisdom of those who have gone before. at http://www.washtimes.com/familytimes/20021230-10862632.htm What to do while traveling at http://www.washtimes.com/familytimes/20021230-54266878.htm      Never underestimate the power of word of mouth. Here, parents and adoption specialists pass on their more valuable nuggets about international adoption travel:      "Ask agencies what kind of services are provided. It needs to be absolutely transparent, itemized and broken down, and you should be able to identify what those costs are. Are you audited every year? What’s your mission statement? When we travel, what kind of support will we have? Will we have training ahead of time? Will we be traveling alone or with a group of other parents? Do you have your own medical staff in that country?" &#8212; Susan Cox, Holt International Children’s Services      "It turned out to be a good thing to be paired up with other adoptive parents [traveling to pick up their children]. Play off their good points. Ours was a schoolteacher. She helped us get through airports, et cetera, and plus she knew how to help us with the children. Being an accountant, I could tell when someone was being overcharged or something like that." &#8212; John Suttora, adoptive parent (Kazakhstan)      "Make sure you’re up to date on hepatitis and tetanus shots, if you need them, which take some time. They’re a series of shots. We basically started them when we started the adoption process. I always carried my vaccination records in my travel documents, clipped to the back of my passport." &#8212; Antonia Siebert, adoptive parent (Guatemala)      "I always recommend people get some sort of [medical-evacuation] insurance, especially traveling to a Third World country. It’s not expensive at all. You can find them online easily enough; SOS is one that comes to mind. When I was a Peace Corps volunteer, we all had it. You want to have an option." &#8212; Bill Strassberger, Immigration and Naturalization Service      "Because it was my second time adopting, I knew that typically with Asian countries at least, the agency staff want to pick you up and take you to the orphanage right away when you arrive. The first time I did that, but I found that after a 33-hour trip I wanted a night’s sleep. I needed to get my bearings and my sea legs before I got my baby." &#8212; Kathy Rafferty, adoptive parent (Cambodia)      "It’s really important not to drink the water. One family put hotel ice in their drink. They were so sick I don’t know how they made it home &#8212; they were the sickest I’ve ever seen anyone. You really have to drink bottled water and also use it for the baby’s bottles." &#8212; Bonnie Horowitz, adoptive parent (Guatemala)      "A major bad thing that happened to us: When we were flying back, we put our video camera in our luggage. The video camera went missing, including the tape. The camera could be replaced, but the tape was all the video we’d taken [in the country], including his foster mom saying goodbye. It’s all gone. It still upsets me." &#8212; Antonia Siebert, adoptive parent (Guatemala)      "You can never go back to that time, even if you go to the country every year. Keep a journal. The memories will become more precious as time goes by. Once you see your child, don’t ever wash the clothes they were in. Let those smells and essence always be." &#8212; Susan Cox, Holt International Children’s Services Are you seriously suggesting keeping dirty clothes from a third world country? The child may have a natural immunity to assorted "bugs" now, but you don’t, and after a few years the child’s immunity may be lost. If you must keep old clothes, at least make sure they are properly washed and maybe fumigated. The Black Death, in Britain, is said to have come into the country in old clothes. (It was carried by fleas that bite infected black rats and humans). After all, one should always wash underwear before use if it comes from a third world country, even if bought new.  Geopelia I think it was pretty good advice, and we kept our kids clothes as were without any need to fumigate anything (the kids needed fumigating more than their clothes but that is another story). And what is the reason "one should always wash underwear before use if it comes from a third world country..?" Finally – I was puzzled by the addition of "… even if bought new." What other options are there?  Used undies? Washing underwear – the most important reason is that you don’t know if the people who have sewn and handled it, often in unhygenic conditions, have any skin diseases etc.

Do you autoclave them before use just to make sure?   IMO this level of paranoia over possible contagion is nonsensical.  If you are this concerned about clothing, it would be interesting to see how you would manage actual travel in developing countries.   Julia – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -But also I have found third world bras especially are full of some kind of material stiffening which needs washing out, or it is very scratchy. I wouldn’t buy Indonesian underwear again, the elastic is of very poor quality and soon needs replacing. (This is not the right newsgroup to talk about the "other options"!) Geopelia Julia More information at http://www.washtimes.com/familytimes/20021230-91551250.htm Books &#8212;      "International Adoption Travel Journal," by Mary Ebejer Petertyl, Folio One Publishing, 2002. This book helps adoptive parents prepare a memento for their children by supplying spaces for itineraries, a daily travel journal, destinations and more.      "Adoption Nation: How the Adoption Revolution is Transforming America," by Adam Pertman, 2000. This Book of the Year Award-winner provides insights into the pleasures and perils of adoption and includes a section on international adoption. Associations &#8212;      Evan B. Donaldson Adoption Institute, 120 Wall St., New York, NY 10005. Phone: 212/269-5080. Web site: www.adoptioninstitute.org. The institute is a national, nonprofit organization devoted to improving adoption policy and practices by improving the quality of information about adoption.      National Adoption Information Clearinghouse, 330 C St. SW, Washington, D.C. 20447. Phone: 703/352-3488. Web site: www.calib.com/naic. This organization, part of the Department of Health and Human Services, is a comprehensive resource on all aspects of adoption. Online &#8212;      AdoptionTravel.com, a for-profit site sponsored by Folio One Publishing, contains tips, travel articles, adoption links and travel resources for those embarking on an overseas trip for adoption.      InternationalAdoption.org is a vast for-profit site with information and resources on topics such as immigration laws, adoption benefits and how to secure a home study.

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – And what is the reason "one should always wash underwear before use if it comes from a third world country..?" Finally – I was puzzled by the addition of "… even if bought new." What other options are there?  Used undies? Washing underwear – the most important reason is that you don’t know if the people who have sewn and handled it, often in unhygenic conditions, have any skin diseases etc.

Would you EVER get a grip? What a load of shite, if you don’t mind my vulgarity.  But also I have found third world bras especially are full of some kind of material stiffening which needs washing out, or it is very scratchy.

Particularly when there is nothing to hold up. I wouldn’t buy Indonesian underwear again, the elastic is of very poor quality and soon needs replacing. (This is not the right newsgroup to talk about the "other options"!)

D’you know something? – you sound like someone playing the part of a drag queen. (A *real* one wouldn’t be so crass) ‘Stupid eejit’ comes to mind, but that is rather too mild…. *Feck off* is probably more appropriate. Helen – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Geopelia Julia More information at http://www.washtimes.com/familytimes/20021230-91551250.htm Books &#8212;      "International Adoption Travel Journal," by Mary Ebejer Petertyl, Folio One Publishing, 2002. This book helps adoptive parents prepare a memento for their children by supplying spaces for itineraries, a daily travel journal, destinations and more.      "Adoption Nation: How the Adoption Revolution is Transforming America," by Adam Pertman, 2000. This Book of the Year Award-winner provides insights into the pleasures and perils of adoption and includes a section on international adoption. Associations &#8212;      Evan B. Donaldson Adoption Institute, 120 Wall St., New York, NY 10005. Phone: 212/269-5080. Web site: www.adoptioninstitute.org. The institute is a national, nonprofit organization devoted to improving adoption policy and practices by improving the quality of information about adoption.      National Adoption Information Clearinghouse, 330 C St. SW, Washington, D.C. 20447. Phone: 703/352-3488. Web site: www.calib.com/naic. This organization, part of the Department of Health and Human Services, is a comprehensive resource on all aspects of adoption. Online &#8212;      AdoptionTravel.com, a for-profit site sponsored by Folio One Publishing, contains tips, travel articles, adoption links and travel resources for those embarking on an overseas trip for adoption.      InternationalAdoption.org is a vast for-profit site with information and resources on topics such as immigration laws, adoption benefits and how to secure a home study.

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Adoption odyessy In the world of adoption travel, flexibility is key and preparation is just about everything else: Choose scrupulous agencies, sharpen skills of consumerism, learn about host countries and listen to the words of wisdom of those who have gone before. at http://www.washtimes.com/familytimes/20021230-10862632.htm What to do while traveling at http://www.washtimes.com/familytimes/20021230-54266878.htm      Never underestimate the power of word of mouth. Here, parents and adoption specialists pass on their more valuable nuggets about international adoption travel:      "Ask agencies what kind of services are provided. It needs to be absolutely transparent, itemized and broken down, and you should be able to identify what those costs are. Are you audited every year? What’s your mission statement? When we travel, what kind of support will we have? Will we have training ahead of time? Will we be traveling alone or with a group of other parents? Do you have your own medical staff in that country?" &#8212; Susan Cox, Holt International Children’s Services      "It turned out to be a good thing to be paired up with other adoptive parents [traveling to pick up their children]. Play off their good points. Ours was a schoolteacher. She helped us get through airports, et cetera, and plus she knew how to help us with the children. Being an accountant, I could tell when someone was being overcharged or something like that." &#8212; John Suttora, adoptive parent (Kazakhstan)      "Make sure you’re up to date on hepatitis and tetanus shots, if you need them, which take some time. They’re a series of shots. We basically started them when we started the adoption process. I always carried my vaccination records in my travel documents, clipped to the back of my passport." &#8212; Antonia Siebert, adoptive parent (Guatemala)      "I always recommend people get some sort of [medical-evacuation] insurance, especially traveling to a Third World country. It’s not expensive at all. You can find them online easily enough; SOS is one that comes to mind. When I was a Peace Corps volunteer, we all had it. You want to have an option." &#8212; Bill Strassberger, Immigration and Naturalization Service      "Because it was my second time adopting, I knew that typically with Asian countries at least, the agency staff want to pick you up and take you to the orphanage right away when you arrive. The first time I did that, but I found that after a 33-hour trip I wanted a night’s sleep. I needed to get my bearings and my sea legs before I got my baby." &#8212; Kathy Rafferty, adoptive parent (Cambodia)      "It’s really important not to drink the water. One family put hotel ice in their drink. They were so sick I don’t know how they made it home &#8212; they were the sickest I’ve ever seen anyone. You really have to drink bottled water and also use it for the baby’s bottles." &#8212; Bonnie Horowitz, adoptive parent (Guatemala)      "A major bad thing that happened to us: When we were flying back, we put our video camera in our luggage. The video camera went missing, including the tape. The camera could be replaced, but the tape was all the video we’d taken [in the country], including his foster mom saying goodbye. It’s all gone. It still upsets me." &#8212; Antonia Siebert, adoptive parent (Guatemala)      "You can never go back to that time, even if you go to the country every year. Keep a journal. The memories will become more precious as time goes by. Once you see your child, don’t ever wash the clothes they were in. Let those smells and essence always be." &#8212; Susan Cox, Holt International Children’s Services Are you seriously suggesting keeping dirty clothes from a third world country? The child may have a natural immunity to assorted "bugs" now, but you don’t, and after a few years the child’s immunity may be lost. If you must keep old clothes, at least make sure they are properly washed and maybe fumigated. The Black Death, in Britain, is said to have come into the country in old clothes. (It was carried by fleas that bite infected black rats and humans). After all, one should always wash underwear before use if it comes from a third world country, even if bought new.  Geopelia I think it was pretty good advice, and we kept our kids clothes as were without any need to fumigate anything (the kids needed fumigating more than their clothes but that is another story). And what is the reason "one should always wash underwear before use if it comes from a third world country..?" Finally – I was puzzled by the addition of "… even if bought new." What other options are there?  Used undies?

Washing underwear – the most important reason is that you don’t know if the people who have sewn and handled it, often in unhygenic conditions, have any skin diseases etc. But also I have found third world bras especially are full of some kind of material stiffening which needs washing out, or it is very scratchy. I wouldn’t buy Indonesian underwear again, the elastic is of very poor quality and soon needs replacing. (This is not the right newsgroup to talk about the "other options"!) Geopelia – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Julia More information at http://www.washtimes.com/familytimes/20021230-91551250.htm Books &#8212;      "International Adoption Travel Journal," by Mary Ebejer Petertyl, Folio One Publishing, 2002. This book helps adoptive parents prepare a memento for their children by supplying spaces for itineraries, a daily travel journal, destinations and more.      "Adoption Nation: How the Adoption Revolution is Transforming America," by Adam Pertman, 2000. This Book of the Year Award-winner provides insights into the pleasures and perils of adoption and includes a section on international adoption. Associations &#8212;      Evan B. Donaldson Adoption Institute, 120 Wall St., New York, NY 10005. Phone: 212/269-5080. Web site: www.adoptioninstitute.org. The institute is a national, nonprofit organization devoted to improving adoption policy and practices by improving the quality of information about adoption.      National Adoption Information Clearinghouse, 330 C St. SW, Washington, D.C. 20447. Phone: 703/352-3488. Web site: www.calib.com/naic. This organization, part of the Department of Health and Human Services, is a comprehensive resource on all aspects of adoption. Online &#8212;      AdoptionTravel.com, a for-profit site sponsored by Folio One Publishing, contains tips, travel articles, adoption links and travel resources for those embarking on an overseas trip for adoption.      InternationalAdoption.org is a vast for-profit site with information and resources on topics such as immigration laws, adoption benefits and how to secure a home study.

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Adoption odyessy In the world of adoption travel, flexibility is key and preparation is just about everything else: Choose scrupulous agencies, sharpen skills of consumerism, learn about host countries and listen to the words of wisdom of those who have gone before. at http://www.washtimes.com/familytimes/20021230-10862632.htm What to do while traveling at http://www.washtimes.com/familytimes/20021230-54266878.htm      Never underestimate the power of word of mouth. Here, parents and adoption specialists pass on their more valuable nuggets about international adoption travel:      "Ask agencies what kind of services are provided. It needs to be absolutely transparent, itemized and broken down, and you should be able to identify what those costs are. Are you audited every year? What’s your mission statement? When we travel, what kind of support will we have? Will we have training ahead of time? Will we be traveling alone or with a group of other parents? Do you have your own medical staff in that country?" &#8212; Susan Cox, Holt International Children’s Services      "It turned out to be a good thing to be paired up with other adoptive parents [traveling to pick up their children]. Play off their good points. Ours was a schoolteacher. She helped us get through airports, et cetera, and plus she knew how to help us with the children. Being an accountant, I could tell when someone was being overcharged or something like that." &#8212; John Suttora, adoptive parent (Kazakhstan)      "Make sure you’re up to date on hepatitis and tetanus shots, if you need them, which take some time. They’re a series of shots. We basically started them when we started the adoption process. I always carried my vaccination records in my travel documents, clipped to the back of my passport." &#8212; Antonia Siebert, adoptive parent (Guatemala)      "I always recommend people get some sort of [medical-evacuation] insurance, especially traveling to a Third World country. It’s not expensive at all. You can find them online easily enough; SOS is one that comes to mind. When I was a Peace Corps volunteer, we all had it. You want to have an option." &#8212; Bill Strassberger, Immigration and Naturalization Service      "Because it was my second time adopting, I knew that typically with Asian countries at least, the agency staff want to pick you up and take you to the orphanage right away when you arrive. The first time I did that, but I found that after a 33-hour trip I wanted a night’s sleep. I needed to get my bearings and my sea legs before I got my baby." &#8212; Kathy Rafferty, adoptive parent (Cambodia)      "It’s really important not to drink the water. One family put hotel ice in their drink. They were so sick I don’t know how they made it home &#8212; they were the sickest I’ve ever seen anyone. You really have to drink bottled water and also use it for the baby’s bottles." &#8212; Bonnie Horowitz, adoptive parent (Guatemala)      "A major bad thing that happened to us: When we were flying back, we put our video camera in our luggage. The video camera went missing, including the tape. The camera could be replaced, but the tape was all the video we’d taken [in the country], including his foster mom saying goodbye. It’s all gone. It still upsets me." &#8212; Antonia Siebert, adoptive parent (Guatemala)      "You can never go back to that time, even if you go to the country every year. Keep a journal. The memories will become more precious as time goes by. Once you see your child, don’t ever wash the clothes they were in. Let those smells and essence always be." &#8212; Susan Cox, Holt International Children’s Services Are you seriously suggesting keeping dirty clothes from a third world country? The child may have a natural immunity to assorted "bugs" now, but you don’t, and after a few years the child’s immunity may be lost. If you must keep old clothes, at least make sure they are properly washed and maybe fumigated. The Black Death, in Britain, is said to have come into the country in old clothes. (It was carried by fleas that bite infected black rats and humans). After all, one should always wash underwear before use if it comes from a third world country, even if bought new.  Geopelia

I think it was pretty good advice, and we kept our kids clothes as were without any need to fumigate anything (the kids needed fumigating more than their clothes but that is another story).   And what is the reason "one should always wash underwear before use if it comes from a third world country..?"   Finally – I was puzzled by the addition of "… even if bought new." What other options are there?  Used undies? Julia – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – More information at http://www.washtimes.com/familytimes/20021230-91551250.htm Books &#8212;      "International Adoption Travel Journal," by Mary Ebejer Petertyl, Folio One Publishing, 2002. This book helps adoptive parents prepare a memento for their children by supplying spaces for itineraries, a daily travel journal, destinations and more.      "Adoption Nation: How the Adoption Revolution is Transforming America," by Adam Pertman, 2000. This Book of the Year Award-winner provides insights into the pleasures and perils of adoption and includes a section on international adoption. Associations &#8212;      Evan B. Donaldson Adoption Institute, 120 Wall St., New York, NY 10005. Phone: 212/269-5080. Web site: www.adoptioninstitute.org. The institute is a national, nonprofit organization devoted to improving adoption policy and practices by improving the quality of information about adoption.      National Adoption Information Clearinghouse, 330 C St. SW, Washington, D.C. 20447. Phone: 703/352-3488. Web site: www.calib.com/naic. This organization, part of the Department of Health and Human Services, is a comprehensive resource on all aspects of adoption. Online &#8212;      AdoptionTravel.com, a for-profit site sponsored by Folio One Publishing, contains tips, travel articles, adoption links and travel resources for those embarking on an overseas trip for adoption.      InternationalAdoption.org is a vast for-profit site with information and resources on topics such as immigration laws, adoption benefits and how to secure a home study.

Response:

Are you seriously suggesting keeping dirty clothes from a third world country? The child may have a natural immunity to assorted "bugs" now, but you don’t, and after a few years the child’s immunity may be lost. If you must keep old clothes, at least make sure they are properly washed and maybe fumigated. The Black Death, in Britain, is said to have come into the country in old clothes. (It was carried by fleas that bite infected black rats and humans). After all, one should always wash underwear before use if it comes from a third world country, even if bought new.  Geopelia

How much travel have you done to Third World countries? If the clothing has fleas, chances are the child will have fleas too. Should we leave her/him behind too? I’m happy to have the clothing my daughter was wearing when we met in China. Roberta mom to Juliette, 6, adopted 2/4/98 from China

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Are you seriously suggesting keeping dirty clothes from a third world country? The child may have a natural immunity to assorted "bugs" now, but you don’t, and after a few years the child’s immunity may be lost. If you must keep old clothes, at least make sure they are properly washed and maybe fumigated. The Black Death, in Britain, is said to have come into the country in old clothes. (It was carried by fleas that bite infected black rats and humans). After all, one should always wash underwear before use if it comes from a third world country, even if bought new.  Geopelia How much travel have you done to Third World countries? If the clothing has fleas, chances are the child will have fleas too. Should we leave her/him behind too?

Of COURSE. We wouldn’t want to encourage the spread of those pesky *foreign* fleas, now would we? I’m happy to have the clothing my daughter was wearing when we met in

China. I should hope so! Helen – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Roberta mom to Juliette, 6, adopted 2/4/98 from China

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Adoption odyessy In the world of adoption travel, flexibility is key and preparation is just about everything else: Choose scrupulous agencies, sharpen skills of consumerism, learn about host countries and listen to the words of wisdom of those who have gone before. at http://www.washtimes.com/familytimes/20021230-10862632.htm What to do while traveling at http://www.washtimes.com/familytimes/20021230-54266878.htm      Never underestimate the power of word of mouth. Here, parents and adoption specialists pass on their more valuable nuggets about international adoption travel:      "Ask agencies what kind of services are provided. It needs to be absolutely transparent, itemized and broken down, and you should be able to identify what those costs are. Are you audited every year? What’s your mission statement? When we travel, what kind of support will we have? Will we have training ahead of time? Will we be traveling alone or with a group of other parents? Do you have your own medical staff in that country?" &#8212; Susan Cox, Holt International Children’s Services      "It turned out to be a good thing to be paired up with other adoptive parents [traveling to pick up their children]. Play off their good points. Ours was a schoolteacher. She helped us get through airports, et cetera, and plus she knew how to help us with the children. Being an accountant, I could tell when someone was being overcharged or something like that." &#8212; John Suttora, adoptive parent (Kazakhstan)      "Make sure you’re up to date on hepatitis and tetanus shots, if you need them, which take some time. They’re a series of shots. We basically started them when we started the adoption process. I always carried my vaccination records in my travel documents, clipped to the back of my passport." &#8212; Antonia Siebert, adoptive parent (Guatemala)      "I always recommend people get some sort of [medical-evacuation] insurance, especially traveling to a Third World country. It’s not expensive at all. You can find them online easily enough; SOS is one that comes to mind. When I was a Peace Corps volunteer, we all had it. You want to have an option." &#8212; Bill Strassberger, Immigration and Naturalization Service      "Because it was my second time adopting, I knew that typically with Asian countries at least, the agency staff want to pick you up and take you to the orphanage right away when you arrive. The first time I did that, but I found that after a 33-hour trip I wanted a night’s sleep. I needed to get my bearings and my sea legs before I got my baby." &#8212; Kathy Rafferty, adoptive parent (Cambodia)      "It’s really important not to drink the water. One family put hotel ice in their drink. They were so sick I don’t know how they made it home &#8212; they were the sickest I’ve ever seen anyone. You really have to drink bottled water and also use it for the baby’s bottles." &#8212; Bonnie Horowitz, adoptive parent (Guatemala)      "A major bad thing that happened to us: When we were flying back, we put our video camera in our luggage. The video camera went missing, including the tape. The camera could be replaced, but the tape was all the video we’d taken [in the country], including his foster mom saying goodbye. It’s all gone. It still upsets me." &#8212; Antonia Siebert, adoptive parent (Guatemala)      "You can never go back to that time, even if you go to the country every year. Keep a journal. The memories will become more precious as time goes by. Once you see your child, don’t ever wash the clothes they were in. Let those smells and essence always be." &#8212; Susan Cox, Holt International Children’s Services

Are you seriously suggesting keeping dirty clothes from a third world country? The child may have a natural immunity to assorted "bugs" now, but you don’t, and after a few years the child’s immunity may be lost. If you must keep old clothes, at least make sure they are properly washed and maybe fumigated. The Black Death, in Britain, is said to have come into the country in old clothes. (It was carried by fleas that bite infected black rats and humans). After all, one should always wash underwear before use if it comes from a third world country, even if bought new.  Geopelia – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – More information at http://www.washtimes.com/familytimes/20021230-91551250.htm Books &#8212;      "International Adoption Travel Journal," by Mary Ebejer Petertyl, Folio One Publishing, 2002. This book helps adoptive parents prepare a memento for their children by supplying spaces for itineraries, a daily travel journal, destinations and more.      "Adoption Nation: How the Adoption Revolution is Transforming America," by Adam Pertman, 2000. This Book of the Year Award-winner provides insights into the pleasures and perils of adoption and includes a section on international adoption. Associations &#8212;      Evan B. Donaldson Adoption Institute, 120 Wall St., New York, NY 10005. Phone: 212/269-5080. Web site: www.adoptioninstitute.org. The institute is a national, nonprofit organization devoted to improving adoption policy and practices by improving the quality of information about adoption.      National Adoption Information Clearinghouse, 330 C St. SW, Washington, D.C. 20447. Phone: 703/352-3488. Web site: www.calib.com/naic. This organization, part of the Department of Health and Human Services, is a comprehensive resource on all aspects of adoption. Online &#8212;      AdoptionTravel.com, a for-profit site sponsored by Folio One Publishing, contains tips, travel articles, adoption links and travel resources for those embarking on an overseas trip for adoption.      InternationalAdoption.org is a vast for-profit site with information and resources on topics such as immigration laws, adoption benefits and how to secure a home study.

Response:

Adoption odyessy In the world of adoption travel, flexibility is key and preparation is just about everything else: Choose scrupulous agencies, sharpen skills of consumerism, learn about host countries and listen to the words of wisdom of those who have gone before. at http://www.washtimes.com/familytimes/20021230-10862632.htm What to do while traveling at http://www.washtimes.com/familytimes/20021230-54266878.htm      Never underestimate the power of word of mouth. Here, parents and adoption specialists pass on their more valuable nuggets about international adoption travel:      "Ask agencies what kind of services are provided. It needs to be absolutely transparent, itemized and broken down, and you should be able to identify what those costs are. Are you audited every year? What’s your mission statement? When we travel, what kind of support will we have? Will we have training ahead of time? Will we be traveling alone or with a group of other parents? Do you have your own medical staff in that country?"

Question:

I am spreading the word about "Adopting Diego & Other Tales of International Adoption," a radio broadcast of interest to adoptees, adopting parents, adoption groups, waiting families and family organizations. It’s an important documentary with a message of hope, generosity, and reaching-out to help others that will enrich your family this holiday season. In the centerpiece story journalist Laurie Stern offers her first person audio essay about the hurdles she overcame to adopt a baby boy from Guatemala. Other segments explore the perspectives of adoptees and the bonds that tie adopting parents to their children’s home countries. "Adopting Diego & Other Tales of International Adoption" is a production of For Kids’ Sake! Radio and is airing nationally in the US and Canada throughout November and December. Please check our updated station list at http://www.forkidssakeradio.com/listeners for local broadcast dates and times. You can also check our list of station Web sites to find out which stations stream their programs online as well as sign up to receive email notification as new stations come on board.

Response:

hi

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I am spreading the word about "Adopting Diego & Other Tales of International Adoption," a radio broadcast of interest to adoptees, adopting parents, adoption groups, waiting families and family organizations. It’s an important documentary with a message of hope, generosity, and reaching-out to help others that will enrich your family this holiday season. In the centerpiece story journalist Laurie Stern offers her first person audio essay about the hurdles she overcame to adopt a baby boy from Guatemala. Other segments explore the perspectives of adoptees and the bonds that tie adopting parents to their children’s home countries. "Adopting Diego & Other Tales of International Adoption" is a production of For Kids’ Sake! Radio and is airing nationally in the US and Canada throughout November and December. Please check our updated station list at http://www.forkidssakeradio.com/listeners for local broadcast dates and times. You can also check our list of station Web sites to find out which stations stream their programs online as well as sign up to receive email notification as new stations come on board.

Response:

kjkk

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I am spreading the word about "Adopting Diego & Other Tales of International Adoption," a radio broadcast of interest to adoptees, adopting parents, adoption groups, waiting families and family organizations. It’s an important documentary with a message of hope, generosity, and reaching-out to help others that will enrich your family this holiday season. In the centerpiece story journalist Laurie Stern offers her first person audio essay about the hurdles she overcame to adopt a baby boy from Guatemala. Other segments explore the perspectives of adoptees and the bonds that tie adopting parents to their children’s home countries. "Adopting Diego & Other Tales of International Adoption" is a production of For Kids’ Sake! Radio and is airing nationally in the US and Canada throughout November and December. Please check our updated station list at http://www.forkidssakeradio.com/listeners for local broadcast dates and times. You can also check our list of station Web sites to find out which stations stream their programs online as well as sign up to receive email notification as new stations come on board.

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – hi I am spreading the word about "Adopting Diego & Other Tales of International Adoption," a radio broadcast of interest to adoptees, adopting parents, adoption groups, waiting families and family organizations. It’s an important documentary with a message of hope, generosity, and reaching-out to help others that will enrich your family this holiday season. In the centerpiece story journalist Laurie Stern offers her first person audio essay about the hurdles she overcame to adopt a baby boy from Guatemala. Other segments explore the perspectives of adoptees and the bonds that tie adopting parents to their children’s home countries. "Adopting Diego & Other Tales of International Adoption" is a production of For Kids’ Sake! Radio and is airing nationally in the US and Canada throughout November and December. Please check our updated station list at http://www.forkidssakeradio.com/listeners for local broadcast dates and times. You can also check our list of station Web sites to find out which stations stream their programs online as well as sign up to receive email notification as new stations come on board.

Response:

Question:

Claudia, I am sorry to tell you this, but we have had nothing but bad experiences with UA.  Every time we have flown them they have screwed up.  They lost our luggage on one occasion, we were not booked on another, we were booked on business class on another – but surprise surprise only one was booked on (to London), so we both got shunted off if we wanted to travel together – did not even try to get my hubby on eco class, put all the stand bys on the plane.  So we both ended up flying to Frankfurt to get to London, hence losing our luggage. Missed our connecting flight, no big deal (to them).  On another occasion they lost our golf clubs. Baggage was broken and open (locks were broken) – this has happened EVERY time we have flown with them and refuse to fly with them anymore. We pay the extra, if there is any.  What more can I say, I gave up flying with them. Sorry for all that bad news, but just to give you an outlook on how we have been treated by them, so don’t fancy your chances. Good luck and if you have a better experience please let me know and maybe I might give them another go, if the service has improved :) BTW, we had our tickets booked a month in advance, so if it is only 2 weeks you may be told NO straight away(or put on standby ho hum).  The flight are always overbooked. — suebo Posted via http://britishexpats.com

Response:

Hard to say what your chances of scoring an upgrade are without knowing your exact travel dates and the availability on those dates. I would think that generally it will be low season after the Chinese New Year… but then lots of business travelers go to Beijing year round. I think that the upgrades are given out based on the fare paid and your FF status, so maybe the time you request it is not that crucial. You might want to go to http://www.flyertalk.com/milesfr.shtml and ask this question on the United forum. And get better answers. P.S. Note that United now requires at least H class ticket for an upgrade by miles (i.e. the cheapest fares are not eligible).

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Hi: We are traveling to China for an international adoption in Febuary (most likely after Chinese New Year.  We will probably be taking United into Beijing from Chicago.  However we won’t be able to book the tickets until about 2 weeks before departure.  We have to wait for travel approval.  Do you think we will be shut out of a ff mile business class upgrade if we wait until then? Thanks for your help. Claudia

Response:

Hi: We are traveling to China for an international adoption in Febuary (most likely after Chinese New Year.  We will probably be taking United into Beijing from Chicago.  However we won’t be able to book the tickets until about 2 weeks before departure.  We have to wait for travel approval.  Do you think we will be shut out of a ff mile business class upgrade if we wait until then? Thanks for your help. Claudia

Response:

Question:

Hi! My husband and I are planning on using Holt International for our International Adoption plans, please need some feedback re: this agency. Or any other recommended agency that we can use. Thanks.

Response:

I suggest you try adopting a kid from your country so that when they are older, and wish to find their parents, it is not such a difficult task. And yes, they all eventually look. Just a heads up. Imagine you are now 30 years old and want to know who your parents are? You have to start looking over seas from 30 years ago, and the records keeping might be much less organized, and then when they do find each other if they are lucky, are they going to be able to afford to visit? Just a suggestion Canadian After Foster Care Site http://afterfostercare.tripod.com

Response:

I suggest you try adopting a kid from your country so that when they are older, and wish to find their parents, it is not such a difficult task. And yes, they all eventually look.

Well, you’re wrong because they don’t all eventually look.  I have an aunt who is in her late 40’s and not only has she not searched, but when my bmom and I offered to pay for, and conduct the search for her, she turned us down flat. In addition, she has the name of her bmom, and bsis and has no desire to find them. Anyhow, it’s fine and dandy to say adopt home grown, unless you don’t fit the profile of the perfect aparent that the agency or organization has. Or, if you have your heart set on a younger child, and don’t want to pay 6 figures to adopt that child, or wait a few more years to do it.  I don’t advocate foreign adoptions in every situation, but there are some that it just makes sense for. I strongly advise all parents adopting internationally to get as much info as possible, in order to facilitate searches later on.  NO ROY, since you undoubtedly are lurking, your reason of not wanting bparents to be able to find you is NOT a good enough reason.

Response:

I want to point out, too, that Holt is on record in support of open records. Marley

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I suggest you try adopting a kid from your country so that when they are older, and wish to find their parents, it is not such a difficult task. And yes, they all eventually look. Well, you’re wrong because they don’t all eventually look.  I have an aunt who is in her late 40’s and not only has she not searched, but when my bmom and I offered to pay for, and conduct the search for her, she turned us down flat. In addition, she has the name of her bmom, and bsis and has no desire to find them. Anyhow, it’s fine and dandy to say adopt home grown, unless you don’t fit the profile of the perfect aparent that the agency or organization has. Or, if you have your heart set on a younger child, and don’t want to pay 6 figures to adopt that child, or wait a few more years to do it.  I don’t advocate foreign adoptions in every situation, but there are some that it just makes sense for. I strongly advise all parents adopting internationally to get as much info as possible, in order to facilitate searches later on.  NO ROY, since you undoubtedly are lurking, your reason of not wanting bparents to be able to find you is NOT a good enough reason.

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I suggest you try adopting a kid from your country so that when they are older, and wish to find their parents, it is not such a difficult task. And yes, they all eventually look. Just a heads up. Imagine you are now 30 years old and want to know who your parents are? You have to start looking over seas from 30 years ago, and the records keeping might be much less organized, and then when they do find each other if they are lucky, are they going to be able to afford to visit? Just a suggestion Canadian After Foster Care Site http://afterfostercare.tripod.com

They all eventually look?  Many/most look … but not all. Search and reunion is likely to be more difficult, and sometimes impossible, for intercountry adoptees – however that is a pretty poor reason IMO to recommend not adopting from overseas.   Those kids exist now, they are almost exclusively in institutional care and their futures without adoption are bleak.  If they are fortunate enough to be adopted within country they are not likely to succeed in a search or reunion (I am unaware of any country sending children abroad for adoption that gives adoptees rights in law, and in most countries they are unlikely to be told they were adopted).  If they remain institutionalised they are likewise unlikely to be able to search.   My children’s access to information was assisted by their intercountry adoptions as our laws give them full access to records here, whereas if they had remained in their birth countries they had no legal rights to those records.  For those who do not have records – search would be impossible no matter where the child was situated. Julia

Response:

Well, you’re wrong because they don’t all eventually look.  I have an aunt who is in her late 40’s and not only has she not searched, but when my bmom and I offered to pay for, and conduct the search for her, she turned us down flat. In addition, she has the name of her bmom, and bsis and has no desire to find them.

I used to think that this woman is a ‘wrong thinker’. I don’t any more. Jackie

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Well, you’re wrong because they don’t all eventually look.  I have an aunt who is in her late 40’s and not only has she not searched, but when my bmom and I offered to pay for, and conduct the search for her, she turned us down flat. In addition, she has the name of her bmom, and bsis and has no desire to find them. I used to think that this woman is a ‘wrong thinker’. I don’t any more. Jackie

It was strange for us, because bmom and I both wanted to know. But, my aunt made an informed decision, and has very logical reasons not to search. I respect each individuals decision regarding search and reunion.

Response:

Hi, I just came across your post on alt. and wanted to let you know I have a neice and nephew from Korea, both adopted through Holt 8 and 9 years ago.  They are the most reputable agency around.  My wife and I are the regional directors in California for European Adoption Consultants, the agency we adopted our two children from two years ago and also a good agency.  I have had the pleasure of meeting representatives from HOLT at adoption symposiums and they are very good people.  If you want an independent opinion look up "The Eastern European Adoption Coalition"  It is a non profit independent website where you can find every international agency listed and then email people who have used them to get good and bad feedback.  Good luck! — Roy

Response:

<< NO ROY, since you undoubtedly are lurking, your reason of not wanting bparents to be able to find you is NOT a good enough reason.

Actually that was not MY reason, but it is a good reason. — Roy

Response:

<< NO ROY, since you undoubtedly are lurking, your reason of not wanting bparents to be able to find you is NOT a good enough reason. Actually that was not MY reason, but it is a good reason. — Roy

You are so full of SHIT. I have lost count on how many times you said your reason for choosing international was primarily to keep the bparents out of the picture, at least for as long as possible.  I should have just googled it, since your track record PROVED you would say that.  

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Well, you’re wrong because they don’t all eventually look.  I have an aunt who is in her late 40’s and not only has she not searched, but when my bmom and I offered to pay for, and conduct the search for her, she turned us down flat. In addition, she has the name of her bmom, and bsis and has no desire to find them. I used to think that this woman is a ‘wrong thinker’. I don’t any more. Jackie It was strange for us, because bmom and I both wanted to know. But, my aunt made an informed decision, and has very logical reasons not to search. I respect each individuals decision regarding search and reunion.

I think that is so important. Jackie

Response:

Question:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Well, what do I get for cleaning out my killfile. "DeannaBefore" Hi there, I was wondering if anyone could give me some more information about the best ways to find someone who was given up for adoption. I am the half-sister of a man who was given for adoption by my birth  mother in 1969, in Ontario, Canada. Gee, Jackie, I can’t help but notice you still don’t give a rat’s about any Ontarion other than yourself (and, of course, my parents – when it suits you). Nice work, bitch.  You’ve done yourself proud. What the fuck are you hissing and spitting about, Deanna? Jackie has some  sort of duty with regard to to everyone in Ontario, according to you? Or were  you just trying to make someone look like a bitch? Nah, just succeeding in making herself look like one. I figured maybe they had a history together. Rh. Obviously you haven’t been around that much. Not that long. Little more than six months, I think – which probably doesn’t amount to even a nanosecond by alt.a time.

LOL  I’m going to step out of this thread too.  Life’s too short and there’s too many other things to worry about then to rehash old crap (which we tend to do endlessly on alt).  

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Well, what do I get for cleaning out my killfile. Hi there, I was wondering if anyone could give me some more information about the best ways to find someone who was given up for adoption. I am the half-sister of a man who was given for adoption by my birth  mother in 1969, in Ontario, Canada. Gee, Jackie, I can’t help but notice you still don’t give a rat’s about any Ontarion other than yourself (and, of course, my parents – when it suits you). Nice work, bitch.  You’ve done yourself proud. What the fuck are you hissing and spitting about, Deanna? Jackie has some  sort of duty with regard to to everyone in Ontario, according to you? Or were  you just trying to make someone look like a bitch? Nah, just succeeding in making herself look like one. I figured maybe they had a history together. Rh. Obviously you haven’t been around that much.

Not that long. Little more than six months, I think – which probably doesn’t amount to even a nanosecond by alt.a time. Rh.

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Well, what do I get for cleaning out my killfile. "DeannaBefore" Hi there, I was wondering if anyone could give me some more information about the best ways to find someone who was given up for adoption. I am the half-sister of a man who was given for adoption by my birth mother in 1969, in Ontario, Canada. Gee, Jackie, I can’t help but notice you still don’t give a rat’s about any Ontarion other than yourself (and, of course, my parents – when it suits you). Nice work, bitch.  You’ve done yourself proud. What the fuck are you hissing and spitting about, Deanna? Jackie has some sort of duty with regard to to everyone in Ontario, according to you? No, but I think she should put her whining to better use.  Jackie pays her taxes in a province that is absolutely dispicable when it comes to adoption issues, a province which is part of a country that is pretty slack overall, and she just doesn’t give a shit.  If she can whine and moan about her what ifs, she can take the time to whine and moan about them in a jurisdiction, and to people, where her whining and moaning might mean something.  I do that myself, and I will hiss and spit at her as much as I like, ta very much. Deanna How dare you call attention to Ontario, you bad, evil adoptee! I dare, just because.  I’m like that. (That was a joke, for anyone who needs guidance.)  For those of you that actually read the messages but don’t already know me, I am a taxpayer in British Columbia and have been for seven years.  However, having had the great misfortune of being placed for adoption in Ontario, where Jackie lives and adoption is, apparently,  an island mecca, and having had the further indignity of paying a stack of useless taxes in that province for decades while not being allowed to ask questions about my origins,  I do feel I am qualified to comment on Ontario adoption practices. Don’t you know that adoption practices in Canada are perfect according to Jackie! Oh, yes, that I did know. She doesn’t give a flying fuck about what is going on in her own backyard, it’s all about evil Amerikan adoption practices.  She "supposedly" advocates open records for all, but is doing nothing about it Canada. Ah, "supposedly".  I like that, with the quotes and all.  Fits very well. Sorry Rev, but I’m siding with D here.  Jackie doesn’t give a poop about adoptees, as you can see from your discourse here.  Twice in the last month, she has publically, in the group (I do believe), said that she has sent her email plus info to stray bmoms looking for info who have wandered in here. Get an adoptee from her province, looking for help?  Forget it.  She’s busy pissing and moaning about Amerikan practices.  Find one post where she has complained about the adoption practices in her own country. Or, at least recognized clear-cut evidence of it. I, and a couple of others have looked up the international adoption boards, where there are just as many Canadian Paps desperately seeking adoptees. Makes ya kinda sick how some of them talk about "better breeding" and all. From what I’ve heard, BC and Newfoundland have open records.  I’d just like to hear what Jackie is doing to promote it for the rest of her country instead of pissing and moaning about hypothetical bmoms in OUR country. I’m turning a little blue, but I’ll always keep the hope. Deanna

I think that "Impact On Mother’s" thread is getting to me.  LOL  I’m just going to killfile it and be done with it.  LOL

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Well, what do I get for cleaning out my killfile. "DeannaBefore" Hi there, I was wondering if anyone could give me some more information about the best ways to find someone who was given up for adoption. I am the half-sister of a man who was given for adoption by my birth mother in 1969, in Ontario, Canada. Gee, Jackie, I can’t help but notice you still don’t give a rat’s about any Ontarion other than yourself (and, of course, my parents – when it suits you). Nice work, bitch.  You’ve done yourself proud. What the fuck are you hissing and spitting about, Deanna? Jackie has some sort of duty with regard to to everyone in Ontario, according to you? Or were you just trying to make someone look like a bitch? Nah, just succeeding in making herself look like one. I figured maybe they had a history together. Rh. Obviously you haven’t been around that much.

Hmmmm. You took the words right out of my mouth. *Who* could forget The War so soon? LOL Helen

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Well, what do I get for cleaning out my killfile. "DeannaBefore" Hi there, I was wondering if anyone could give me some more information about the best ways to find someone who was given up for adoption. I am the half-sister of a man who was given for adoption by my birth mother in 1969, in Ontario, Canada. Gee, Jackie, I can’t help but notice you still don’t give a rat’s about any Ontarion other than yourself (and, of course, my parents – when it suits you). Nice work, bitch.  You’ve done yourself proud. What the fuck are you hissing and spitting about, Deanna? Jackie has some sort of duty with regard to to everyone in Ontario, according to you? Or were you just trying to make someone look like a bitch? Nah, just succeeding in making herself look like one. I figured maybe they had a history together. Rh. Obviously you haven’t been around that much. Hmmmm. You took the words right out of my mouth. *Who* could forget The War so soon? LOL

Loose my number. LOL Helen

Kathy "To err is human; to forgive, divine."

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Well, what do I get for cleaning out my killfile. "DeannaBefore" Hi there, I was wondering if anyone could give me some more information about the best ways to find someone who was given up for adoption. I am the half-sister of a man who was given for adoption by my birth mother in 1969, in Ontario, Canada. Gee, Jackie, I can’t help but notice you still don’t give a rat’s about any Ontarion other than yourself (and, of course, my parents – when it suits you). Nice work, bitch.  You’ve done yourself proud. What the fuck are you hissing and spitting about, Deanna? Jackie has some sort of duty with regard to to everyone in Ontario, according to you? No, but I think she should put her whining to better use.  Jackie pays her taxes in a province that is absolutely dispicable when it comes to adoption issues, a province which is part of a country that is pretty slack overall, and she just doesn’t give a shit.  If she can whine and moan about her what ifs, she can take the time to whine and moan about them in a jurisdiction, and to people, where her whining and moaning might mean something.  I do that myself, and I will hiss and spit at her as much as I like, ta very much. Deanna How dare you call attention to Ontario, you bad, evil adoptee!

I dare, just because.  I’m like that. (That was a joke, for anyone who needs guidance.)  For those of you that actually read the messages but don’t already know me, I am a taxpayer in British Columbia and have been for seven years.  However, having had the great misfortune of being placed for adoption in Ontario, where Jackie lives and adoption is, apparently,  an island mecca, and having had the further indignity of paying a stack of useless taxes in that province for decades while not being allowed to ask questions about my origins,  I do feel I am qualified to comment on Ontario adoption practices. Don’t you know that adoption practices in Canada are perfect according to Jackie!

Oh, yes, that I did know. She doesn’t give a flying fuck about what is going on in her own backyard, it’s all about evil Amerikan adoption practices.  She "supposedly" advocates open records for all, but is doing nothing about it Canada.

Ah, "supposedly".  I like that, with the quotes and all.  Fits very well. Sorry Rev, but I’m siding with D here.  Jackie doesn’t give a poop about adoptees, as you can see from your discourse here.  Twice in the last month, she has publically, in the group (I do believe), said that she has sent her email plus info to stray bmoms looking for info who have wandered in here. Get an adoptee from her province, looking for help?  Forget it.  She’s busy pissing and moaning about Amerikan practices.  Find one post where she has complained about the adoption practices in her own country.

Or, at least recognized clear-cut evidence of it. I, and a couple of others have looked up the international adoption boards, where there are just as many Canadian Paps desperately seeking adoptees. Makes ya kinda sick how some of them talk about "better breeding" and all. From what I’ve heard, BC and Newfoundland have open records.  I’d just like to hear what Jackie is doing to promote it for the rest of her country instead of pissing and moaning about hypothetical bmoms in OUR country.

I’m turning a little blue, but I’ll always keep the hope. Deanna

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Well, what do I get for cleaning out my killfile. Hi there, I was wondering if anyone could give me some more information about the best ways to find someone who was given up for adoption. I am the half-sister of a man who was given for adoption by my birth mother in 1969, in Ontario, Canada. Gee, Jackie, I can’t help but notice you still don’t give a rat’s about any Ontarion other than yourself (and, of course, my parents – when it suits you). Nice work, bitch.  You’ve done yourself proud. What the fuck are you hissing and spitting about, Deanna? Jackie has some sort of duty with regard to to everyone in Ontario, according to you? No, but I think she should put her whining to better use.  Jackie pays her taxes in a province that is absolutely dispicable when it comes to adoption issues, a province which is part of a country that is pretty slack overall, and she just doesn’t give a shit.  If she can whine and moan about her what ifs, she can take the time to whine and moan about them in a jurisdiction, and to people, where her whining and moaning might mean something.  I do that myself, and I will hiss and spit at her as much as I like, ta very much. Deanna

How dare you call attention to Ontario, you bad, evil adoptee!  Don’t you know that adoption practices in Canada are perfect according to Jackie!  She doesn’t give a flying fuck about what is going on in her own backyard, it’s all about evil Amerikan adoption practices.  She "supposedly" advocates open records for all, but is doing nothing about it Canada. Sorry Rev, but I’m siding with D here.  Jackie doesn’t give a poop about adoptees, as you can see from your discourse here.  Twice in the last month, she has publically, in the group (I do believe), said that she has sent her email plus info to stray bmoms looking for info who have wandered in here. Get an adoptee from her province, looking for help?  Forget it.  She’s busy pissing and moaning about Amerikan practices.  Find one post where she has complained about the adoption practices in her own country. I, and a couple of others have looked up the international adoption boards, where there are just as many Canadian Paps desperately seeking adoptees.  Makes ya kinda sick how some of them talk about "better breeding" and all. From what I’ve heard, BC and Newfoundland have open records.  I’d just like to hear what Jackie is doing to promote it for the rest of her country instead of pissing and moaning about hypothetical bmoms in OUR country.  JMO, of course.

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Well, what do I get for cleaning out my killfile. "DeannaBefore" Hi there, I was wondering if anyone could give me some more information about the best ways to find someone who was given up for adoption. I am the half-sister of a man who was given for adoption by my birth mother in 1969, in Ontario, Canada. Gee, Jackie, I can’t help but notice you still don’t give a rat’s about any Ontarion other than yourself (and, of course, my parents – when it suits you). Nice work, bitch.  You’ve done yourself proud. What the fuck are you hissing and spitting about, Deanna? Jackie has some sort of duty with regard to to everyone in Ontario, according to you? Or were you just trying to make someone look like a bitch? Nah, just succeeding in making herself look like one. I figured maybe they had a history together.

Which we do. Deanna

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Well, what do I get for cleaning out my killfile. Hi there, I was wondering if anyone could give me some more information about the best ways to find someone who was given up for adoption. I am the half-sister of a man who was given for adoption by my birth mother in 1969, in Ontario, Canada. Gee, Jackie, I can’t help but notice you still don’t give a rat’s about any Ontarion other than yourself (and, of course, my parents – when it suits you). Nice work, bitch.  You’ve done yourself proud. What the fuck are you hissing and spitting about, Deanna? Jackie has some sort of duty with regard to to everyone in Ontario, according to you?

No, but I think she should put her whining to better use.  Jackie pays her taxes in a province that is absolutely dispicable when it comes to adoption issues, a province which is part of a country that is pretty slack overall, and she just doesn’t give a shit.  If she can whine and moan about her what ifs, she can take the time to whine and moan about them in a jurisdiction, and to people, where her whining and moaning might mean something.  I do that myself, and I will hiss and spit at her as much as I like, ta very much. Deanna

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Well, what do I get for cleaning out my killfile. Hi there, I was wondering if anyone could give me some more information about the best ways to find someone who was given up for adoption. I am the half-sister of a man who was given for adoption by my birth mother in 1969, in Ontario, Canada. Gee, Jackie, I can’t help but notice you still don’t give a rat’s about any Ontarion other than yourself (and, of course, my parents – when it suits you). Nice work, bitch.  You’ve done yourself proud. What the fuck are you hissing and spitting about, Deanna? Jackie has some sort of duty with regard to to everyone in Ontario, according to you? Or were you just trying to make someone look like a bitch?

She certainly has SOMEONE looking like a bitch. steve

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Well, what do I get for cleaning out my killfile. Hi there, I was wondering if anyone could give me some more information about the best ways to find someone who was given up for adoption. I am the half-sister of a man who was given for adoption by my birth mother in 1969, in Ontario, Canada. Gee, Jackie, I can’t help but notice you still don’t give a rat’s about any Ontarion other than yourself (and, of course, my parents – when it suits you). Nice work, bitch.  You’ve done yourself proud. What the fuck are you hissing and spitting about, Deanna? Jackie has some sort of duty with regard to to everyone in Ontario, according to you? Or were you just trying to make someone look like a bitch?

Nah, just succeeding in making herself look like one. I figured maybe they had a history together. Rh. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – whoever killcoffee

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Well, what do I get for cleaning out my killfile. Hi there, I was wondering if anyone could give me some more information about the best ways to find someone who was given up for adoption. I am the half-sister of a man who was given for adoption by my birth mother in 1969, in Ontario, Canada. Gee, Jackie, I can’t help but notice you still don’t give a rat’s about any Ontarion other than yourself (and, of course, my parents – when it suits you). Nice work, bitch.  You’ve done yourself proud. What the fuck are you hissing and spitting about, Deanna? Jackie has some sort of duty with regard to to everyone in Ontario, according to you? Or were you just trying to make someone look like a bitch? Nah, just succeeding in making herself look like one. I figured maybe they had a history together. Rh.

Obviously you haven’t been around that much.

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Hi there, I was wondering if anyone could give me some more information about the best ways to find someone who was given up for adoption. I am the half-sister of a man who was given for adoption by my birth mother in 1969, in Ontario, Canada. Gee, Jackie, I can’t help but notice you still don’t give a rat’s about any Ontarion other than yourself (and, of course, my parents – when it suits you). Nice work, bitch.  You’ve done yourself proud. Deanna

So if I help this person will I have done my penance? Will all be forgiven? Will I become a good birth mother? Jackie

Response:

Well, what do I get for cleaning out my killfile. Hi there, I was wondering if anyone could give me some more information about the best ways to find someone who was given up for adoption. I am the half-sister of a man who was given for adoption by my birth mother in 1969, in Ontario, Canada. Gee, Jackie, I can’t help but notice you still don’t give a rat’s about any Ontarion other than yourself (and, of course, my parents – when it suits you). Nice work, bitch.  You’ve done yourself proud.

What the fuck are you hissing and spitting about, Deanna? Jackie has some sort of duty with regard to to everyone in Ontario, according to you? Or were you just trying to make someone look like a bitch? whoever killcoffee

Response:

Hi there, I was wondering if anyone could give me some more information about the best ways to find someone who was given up for adoption. I am the half-sister of a man who was given for adoption by my birth mother in 1969, in Ontario, Canada.

Gee, Jackie, I can’t help but notice you still don’t give a rat’s about any Ontarion other than yourself (and, of course, my parents – when it suits you). Nice work, bitch.  You’ve done yourself proud. Deanna

Response:

Hi there, I was wondering if anyone could give me some more information about the best ways to find someone who was given up for adoption. I am the half-sister of a man who was given for adoption by my birth mother in 1969, in Ontario, Canada. She is currently searching for him by mail, and I am looking for resources on the internet. Any info would be appreciated. Is it common for people who are searching for their birth parent(s) to post on this newsgroup? Are there any others I should try? etc…. Also, if anyone reading this is looking for their birth mother: You are a male, born on June 1, 1969, in Toronto, Ontario. You were adopted out of Halton County. The name given to you by your birth mother was originally Matthew Blezard, but you may not know this. If this sounds at all like you, or you have any information for me, please email me a.s.a.p. at Thanks!

You might try ‘The Adoptee Searcher’s Handbook’, which can be found on-line at:   www.ouareau.com/adoptee Good luck. Rh.

Response:

Hi there, I was wondering if anyone could give me some more information about the best ways to find someone who was given up for adoption. I am the half-sister of a man who was given for adoption by my birth mother in 1969, in Ontario, Canada. She is currently searching for him by mail, and I am looking for resources on the internet. Any info would be appreciated. Is it common for people who are searching for their birth parent(s) to post on this newsgroup? Are there any others I should try? etc…. Also, if anyone reading this is looking for their birth mother: You are a male, born on June 1, 1969, in Toronto, Ontario. You were adopted out of Halton County. The name given to you by your birth mother was originally Matthew Blezard, but you may not know this. If this sounds at all like you, or you have any information for me, please email me a.s.a.p. at Thanks!

Response:

Make sure you register the Canadian Adoptees Registry at http://www.canadianadopteesregistry.org/index.html Roy Kading LINKS Post Legal Adoption Support Group http://members.shaw.ca/rkading – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Hi there, I was wondering if anyone could give me some more information about the best ways to find someone who was given up for adoption. I am the half-sister of a man who was given for adoption by my birth mother in 1969, in Ontario, Canada. She is currently searching for him by mail, and I am looking for resources on the internet. Any info would be appreciated. Is it common for people who are searching for their birth parent(s) to post on this newsgroup? Are there any others I should try? etc…. Also, if anyone reading this is looking for their birth mother: You are a male, born on June 1, 1969, in Toronto, Ontario. You were adopted out of Halton County. The name given to you by your birth mother was originally Matthew Blezard, but you may not know this. If this sounds at all like you, or you have any information for me, please email me a.s.a.p. at Thanks!

Response:

Thanks. I already registered there (at the Canadian Adoptees Registry), it just hasn’t shown up yet. Anyone know of anywhere else where you can register online & not just by ("snail") mail? Appreciate it. -Jess.

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Make sure you register the Canadian Adoptees Registry at http://www.canadianadopteesregistry.org/index.html Roy Kading LINKS Post Legal Adoption Support Group http://members.shaw.ca/rkading Hi there, I was wondering if anyone could give me some more information about the best ways to find someone who was given up for adoption. I am the half-sister of a man who was given for adoption by my birth mother in 1969, in Ontario, Canada. She is currently searching for him by mail, and I am looking for resources on the internet. Any info would be appreciated. Is it common for people who are searching for their birth parent(s) to post on this newsgroup? Are there any others I should try? etc…. Also, if anyone reading this is looking for their birth mother: You are a male, born on June 1, 1969, in Toronto, Ontario. You were adopted out of Halton County. The name given to you by your birth mother was originally Matthew Blezard, but you may not know this. If this sounds at all like you, or you have any information for me, please email me a.s.a.p. at Thanks!

Response:

Thanks. I already registered there (at the Canadian Adoptees Registry), it just hasn’t shown up yet. Anyone know of anywhere else where you can register online & not just by ("snail") mail? Appreciate it. -Jess.

Actually, as far as online resources go for Canada, the CAR is about the best you can do (no offence, Mr. Kading – you do an excellent job). I have sent you a private message, but if you need more assistance, please feel free to get in touch, & thanks, Roy. Deanna

Response:

Question:

as promised.  I apologize for inadvertently including your son when I called you a neanderthal.  That was not fair and uncalled for to include  your son. My apology has nothing to do with your blackmail of me by saying you will continue to post my personal information, putting my children in danger until I apologize.  I am doing it simply because it is the right thing to do.

If it was the right thing to do, why didn’t you apologize right after you wrote it?

Response:

as promised.  I apologize for inadvertently including your son when I called you a neanderthal.  That was not fair and uncalled for to include  your son. My apology has nothing to do with your blackmail of me by saying you will continue to post my personal information, putting my children in danger until I apologize.  I am doing it simply because it is the right thing to do.

What are you going on about? Your "personal information" is splashed on a webpage you use to advertise your professional services, you dimwit. You stand in a supermarket parking lot with your pants around your ankles and then get mad when someone points and says, "Hey, look at that guys dinkie!"

Response:

as promised.  I apologize for inadvertently including your son when I called you a neanderthal.

Hardly "inadvertant".  You had to type it, after all.  That was not fair and uncalled for to include  your son. My apology has nothing to do with your blackmail of me by saying you will continue to post my personal information, putting my children in danger until I apologize.

<sigh  Roy, I was just quoting you.  Should I attribute your words to someone else?  I told you if it makes you so uncomfortable then perhaps you’d be better off not posting at all.  You and your words will quickly be forgotten.  After all, you’re the one who has his "personal information" splattered all over the www.  If your children are in any danger (which I doubt) it has nothing to do with me and everything to do with the information you have provided as an "adoption expert and professional" and the way you have conducted yourself both here and on AOL.  The attribution to your quotes are quite topical as you have continually said that your opinions are reflective of those whom you have encountered in your work with the EAC in California.  For those in CA who wish to pursue an international adoption but would like to be spared your vitriol perhaps it would informative to them as they can skip right on past your organization and move on to the next saving both time and aggravation. I am doing it simply because it is the right thing to do. Uh huh.  You’re a real saint. Jack Bernhard -Some guy in Connecticut

Response:

as promised.  I apologize for inadvertently including your son when I called you a neanderthal.  That was not fair and uncalled for to include  your son. My apology has nothing to do with your blackmail of me by saying you will continue to post my personal information, putting my children in danger until I apologize.  I am doing it simply because it is the right thing to do.

Response:

Question:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Will be flying with 3 grandchildren, 8, 5 and 2.  Dumb question, but do they need photo ID? Thanks probably not but you will need documentation that you are authorized to fly with children not your own. When I fly with my child, they don’t ask for proof that is my child. so you recommend that the grandparents chance it?  good advice

Her grandparents have never been asked for proof of this on a domestic flight. Have you ever heard of this for people traveling together on a domestic flight?

Response:

In Canada travelling from Calgary to Halifax I was asked to provide proof of my child’s relationship to me…and my marital status by the ticket agent. I was not harassed but was made aware of the situation of child abduction. I thought it was conscientious of the airlines to do their part. From that point on we always travelled with appropriate documentation. Heather

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – "Jack Will be flying with 3 grandchildren, 8, 5 and 2.  Dumb question, but do they need photo ID? Thanks probably not but you will need documentation that you are authorized to fly with children not your own. When I fly with my child, they don’t ask for proof that is my child. so you recommend that the grandparents chance it?  good advice Her grandparents have never been asked for proof of this on a domestic flight. Have you ever heard of this for people traveling together on a domestic flight?

Response:

Maybe not in your situation but I have been asked for it in the past for my children and since then they have had their own passports. It’s not worth the hassle to risk it. If you ever get asked and can’t provide it the time it takes to straighten the situation could ruin the whole vacation. Take a little time beforehand and things will go smoothly. Heather

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Will be flying with 3 grandchildren, 8, 5 and 2.  Dumb question, but do they need photo ID? Thanks No photo idea is needed.

Response:

If only one has custody then you need a notarized signature from them and a copy of the document giving them sole custody.  If traveling outside of the English speaking world you may be expected to have them in the language of the places you are visiting.

This doesn’t relate exactly to the original message, but it got me thinking: What about cases where the parents are not divorced, but only one is travelling with the child? Next month my sister will by flying with her daughter to Canada.  My brother-in-law will not go with them because he has to work. Does my sister need to bring something with her that indicates that her husband has given her permission to take their daughter? It seems unlikely that rules like this would apply in the case of married couples, but you never know. Ed

Response:

it would depend on which country they were going to but for example for entry into Canada (from the state department’s page): —start CHILDREN’S ISSUES: Many governments, including Canada’s, have initiated procedures at entry and exit points to prevent international child abduction, including requiring documentary evidence of relationship and permission of the parent(s) or legal guardian not present for the child’s travel. Having such documentation on hand, even if not required, may facilitate entry and departure. For further information on international adoption of children and international parental child abduction, please refer to our Internet site at http://travel.state.gov/children’s_issues.html or telephone (202) 736-7000. —end It’s spelled out better for some other countries, but if you were to follow the advice of the State Department, you would need a notarized permission note from the parent not traveling

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – This doesn’t relate exactly to the original message, but it got me thinking: What about cases where the parents are not divorced, but only one is travelling with the child? Next month my sister will by flying with her daughter to Canada.  My brother-in-law will not go with them because he has to work. Does my sister need to bring something with her that indicates that her husband has given her permission to take their daughter? It seems unlikely that rules like this would apply in the case of married couples, but you never know. Ed

Response:

I sure would have written documentation/permission even if the parents are not divorced. This was the exact case of a couple from Stratford, Ontario. They weren’t divorced just separated. She departed Canada for Mexico. Authotities didn’t know of the separation. This was a case of kidnapping but due the the fact that she was the mother/wife she got off scott free. If it had of been the Father/husband who did this he would be in jail <ramble off. Better to have the documents/permission in writing and notarized. Good Luck Bill

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – If only one has custody then you need a notarized signature from them and a copy of the document giving them sole custody.  If traveling outside of the English speaking world you may be expected to have them in the language of the places you are visiting. This doesn’t relate exactly to the original message, but it got me thinking: What about cases where the parents are not divorced, but only one is travelling with the child? Next month my sister will by flying with her daughter to Canada.  My brother-in-law will not go with them because he has to work. Does my sister need to bring something with her that indicates that her husband has given her permission to take their daughter? It seems unlikely that rules like this would apply in the case of married couples, but you never know. Ed

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Thanks, and what kind and where would a person get that type of doc’s, the parents? A copy of each kids’ birth certificate would probably be okay. Check with the airline. I am sure they get this situation all the time. a copy of the child’s birth certificate does not provide authorization for non parents to be whisking them about the country If they were going out of the country, they wouldn’t have  been asking about photo id.

a total non sequitor

Response:

Thanks, and what kind and where would a person get that type of doc’s, the parents?

A copy of each kids’ birth certificate would probably be okay. Check with the airline. I am sure they get this situation all the time.

Response:

Will be flying with 3 grandchildren, 8, 5 and 2.  Dumb question, but do they need photo ID?

No, but you may need Valium.  :-) A recent newspaper article said that the parental permission is extremely important for international travel.  Many immigration agencies are under pressure to prevent custody "kidnappings" and illegal adoptions. For any travel, be sure you have a note authorizing you to make medical decisions and get treatment for the grandkids. Enjoy your trip…your grandchildren are lucky! Ken Ishiguro

Response:

Will be flying with 3 grandchildren, 8, 5 and 2.  Dumb question, but do they need photo ID? Thanks

No photo idea is needed.

Response:

Will be flying with 3 grandchildren, 8, 5 and 2.  Dumb question, but do they need photo ID? Thanks probably not but you will need documentation that you are authorized to fly with children not your own.

When I fly with my child, they don’t ask for proof that is my child.

Response:

Thanks, and what kind and where would a person get that type of doc’s, the parents? A copy of each kids’ birth certificate would probably be okay. Check with the airline. I am sure they get this situation all the time.

a copy of the child’s birth certificate does not provide authorization for non parents to be whisking them about the country

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Thanks, and what kind and where would a person get that type of doc’s, the parents? A copy of each kids’ birth certificate would probably be okay. Check with the airline. I am sure they get this situation all the time. a copy of the child’s birth certificate does not provide authorization for non parents to be whisking them about the country

If they were going out of the country, they wouldn’t have  been asking about photo id.

Response:

Will be flying with 3 grandchildren, 8, 5 and 2.  Dumb question, but do they need photo ID? Thanks probably not but you will need documentation that you are authorized to fly with children not your own.

unless this is an international flight, in which case they’ll need passports like normal people

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Will be flying with 3 grandchildren, 8, 5 and 2.  Dumb question, but do they need photo ID? Thanks probably not but you will need documentation that you are authorized to fly with children not your own. unless this is an international flight, in which case they’ll need passports like normal people

well of course.

Response:

(snip) if the children have divorced parents you will need the permission of both parents. Wouldn’t you only need permission from the custodial parent? I could see needing permission from both if they had joint custody, but not if only one has custody.

Response:

It will of course depend on what airline and where you are flying.  Delta for example does not require ID for anybody under 18 domestically.  Call the airline to see what you need. You will probably need notarized letters from the parents authorizing you to take the children, again depending on the situation and where you are going it will have to be from both parents or if one  has custody then from them and a copy of the reason for sole custody (divorce papers, death certificate, etc) You will probably never be asked for the papers, but it’s certainly better to have them and not need them then not to have them and need them.

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Will be flying with 3 grandchildren, 8, 5 and 2.  Dumb question, but do they need photo ID? Thanks

Response:

If only one has custody then you need a notarized signature from them and a copy of the document giving them sole custody.  If traveling outside of the English speaking world you may be expected to have them in the language of the places you are visiting. Probably never be asked for, but that is the requirement for most countries. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – (snip) if the children have divorced parents you will need the permission of both parents. Wouldn’t you only need permission from the custodial parent? I could see needing permission from both if they had joint custody, but not if only one has custody.

Response:

has custody then you need a notarized signature from them and a copy of the document giving them sole custody.  If traveling outside of the English speaking world you may be expected to have them in the language of the places you are visiting. Probably never be asked for, but that is the requirement for most

countries. This is the correct advice as I know it. Our daughter travelled with a friend’s family outside the country. We literally gave them temporary custody of our daughter. She had her own passport. We had affidavits giving them permission to deal with medical emergencies and siting them as temporary guardians. It made the whole trip much easier. They were asked at the airport to provide the documentation..they did..zoom ..they were on their way. Make sure you have the medical insurance information for each child. My children at young ages ..even when with us.. travelled with their home address in thier pockets and a complete flight itinerary. Contact a lawyer and get the proper advice for your situation. It will make your trip a whole lot smoother in the long run. Heather

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Will be flying with 3 grandchildren, 8, 5 and 2.  Dumb question, but do they need photo ID? Thanks probably not but you will need documentation that you are authorized to fly with children not your own. When I fly with my child, they don’t ask for proof that is my child.

so you recommend that the grandparents chance it?  good advice

Response:

Will be flying with 3 grandchildren, 8, 5 and 2.  Dumb question, but do they need photo ID? Thanks

Response:

Will be flying with 3 grandchildren, 8, 5 and 2.  Dumb question, but do they need photo ID? Thanks

probably not but you will need documentation that you are authorized to fly with children not your own.

Response:

Thanks, and what kind and where would a person get that type of doc’s, the parents? Thanks

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Will be flying with 3 grandchildren, 8, 5 and 2.  Dumb question, but do they need photo ID? Thanks probably not but you will need documentation that you are authorized to fly with children not your own.

Response:

Thanks, and what kind and where would a person get that type of doc’s, the parents?

You need to get authoritative advice on this — not opinions on the net — but generally the parents need to provide notorized statements authorizing travel and permission for medical power of attorney etc. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Thanks Will be flying with 3 grandchildren, 8, 5 and 2.  Dumb question, but do they need photo ID? Thanks probably not but you will need documentation that you are authorized to fly with children not your own.

Response:

from the parents and make sure it is notarized especially if you are leaving the country. you will also need the medical /health insurance docs with you and release for you to seek medical help for them if necessary.if the children have divorced parents you will need the permission of both parents. — – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Thanks, and what kind and where would a person get that type of doc’s, the parents? Thanks Will be flying with 3 grandchildren, 8, 5 and 2.  Dumb question, but do they need photo ID? Thanks probably not but you will need documentation that you are authorized to fly with children not your own.

Response: